I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: in a commercial lease, net rent is a fixed number. The charge that moves — and that produces an extra bill at year-end — is the additional rent known as TMI. It is collected monthly on an estimate and reconciled against actual costs once a year, with the difference settled either way. If you sign without pinning down what it includes, how it is shared and whether you may audit it, you have effectively agreed that the landlord's year-end number is final. This article explains the mechanics and the protections.
One point of orientation: the contents of TMI are a matter of contract. Ontario has no standard commercial lease, and the Commercial Tenancies Act does not supply the list for you. One element is statutory, though: commercial rent is a taxable supply, so 13% HST in Ontario is charged on net rent and additional rent alike, under the federal Excise Tax Act and the CRA's published Ontario rate. A tenant registered for HST can generally claim input tax credits as the rules allow — ask your accountant about your own position.
First: what TMI is, and how it is collected
TMI stands for Taxes, Maintenance and Insurance. You pay a proportionate share — usually based on your area — of the building's operating costs in those three categories. CAM (common area maintenance) is generally the name for the maintenance portion, as the lease defines it; it is not usually a separate extra charge on top.
Collection runs in two steps:
| Stage | How it works |
|---|---|
| Monthly during the year | The landlord sets an estimate per square foot per year; you pay it monthly with net rent, plus 13% HST |
| Year-end reconciliation | The landlord totals actual costs, applies your share, and compares it with what you paid: pay the shortfall, or receive a credit if you overpaid |
An illustrative example with numbers I invented: you lease 1,500 square feet at an estimated TMI of $10 per square foot per year, so you pay $15,000 across the year. Actual costs come in at $11 per square foot, making your share $16,500 — you owe a $1,500 adjustment (plus applicable HST). If actual costs were $9, you would be owed a $1,500 credit. The adjustment bill itself is not the landlord cheating; it is how the structure works — provided the underlying costs are properly chargeable.
Second: which costs should not land in your additional rent
Most reconciliation fights are really about one question: what counts as an operating cost? Getting the exclusions listed in the lease beats arguing every December. Tenants commonly seek to exclude, or deal with separately:
- Capital replacements: a new roof, structural work or a full HVAC replacement extends the property's life and is capital in nature. It should not be dropped into one year's operating costs whole; if the lease allows amortization, the period and method should be stated.
- Leasing costs: commissions, marketing and fit-out costs for attracting new tenants or for vacant units should not be shared by tenants already in place.
- The landlord's own financing and overhead: mortgage interest and the landlord's legal and accounting fees are generally not the tenants' burden. If a management fee is charged, its rate and basis should be written down.
- Double recovery: a cost recovered through a separate charge cannot be counted again inside TMI.
Also ask about the denominator. Is your share calculated over the building's total area, or only over leased area? Who carries the share attributable to vacant units? The denominator alone can move your percentage by a meaningful amount.
Third: the three protections to negotiate before signing
First, a cap on controllable costs. Taxes and insurance move with the market and are hard to cap; maintenance and management-type costs are comparatively controllable, so seek an annual cap on their increases, with excess costs borne by the landlord or dealt with as the lease states.
Second, an audit right. Write in how long after a reconciliation you may demand the cost detail and supporting records, how quickly the landlord must produce them, and how overcharges are corrected. A reconciliation you cannot inspect is a number you can only believe or disbelieve.
Third, history. Before signing, ask for two or three years of actual additional rent figures — not just this year's estimate. An estimate set well below recent actuals makes a year-end adjustment bill nearly certain, and that belongs on the negotiating table now.
Three common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "The TMI in the listing is the final number." It is an estimate, reconciled to actual cost at year-end. Budgeting on it as a fixed price is how the December adjustment bill becomes a shock.
Misunderstanding 2: "CAM is another charge on top of TMI." Usually not. CAM refers to common area maintenance costs and is generally inside the maintenance portion of additional rent. What is included is a matter of the lease's definitions — read them rather than guessing from the acronym.
Misunderstanding 3: "There is no HST on additional rent." There is. Net rent and additional rent under a commercial lease are both taxable supplies, charged at 13% in Ontario. Leave it out of your occupancy-cost math and your monthly figure is understated by a wide margin; whether you can recover it as an input tax credit is a question for your accountant.
If you are about to sign a net lease, I suggest this order
- Get two or three years of actual additional rent figures and set them beside the landlord's estimate; ask about any gap before anything else.
- Confirm item by item what additional rent includes, and write the exclusions — capital replacements, leasing costs, landlord financing costs — into the lease.
- Ask whether your share is calculated on total area or leased area, who carries vacant space, and put the answer in the clause.
- Negotiate three things: a cap on controllable cost increases, an audit right after reconciliation, and a firm timetable for statements and adjustments.
- When each year's statement arrives, do not pay it on sight: check the major categories against the lease definitions first, use the audit right if the numbers look off, and have your accountant confirm the HST treatment.
I am Ming Ren. With a commercial lease, settle the additional rent first, and argue about net rent second.
This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. The scope, sharing and reconciliation of additional rent are contractual lease terms; consult your accountant on HST treatment and an Ontario lawyer on disputes.
Primary sources: Commercial Tenancies Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.7 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026); Excise Tax Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. E-15, s.165, and the CRA-published Ontario GST/HST rate of 13%. The $10 per-square-foot and 1,500-square-foot figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction.


