I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion: what everyone calls "CMHC insurance" is mortgage default insurance, and it protects the lender, not you. If you stop paying, the insurance covers the bank's loss — your debt does not disappear. It can feel odd to pay for someone else's protection, but what it buys you is real: the ability to purchase with less than 20% down, usually at interest rates comparable to those offered to large-down-payment borrowers. Once you can do this arithmetic, you can judge whether it is worth it for you.
Who must buy it, and who cannot
The rules are federal, and CMHC states them plainly:
| Situation | Insurance position |
|---|---|
| Down payment under 20% of the price | Default insurance is mandatory (arranged by the lender through CMHC, Sagen or Canada Guaranty) |
| Down payment of 20% or more | Not required (a lender may still insure some loans on its own account — a different matter) |
| Price of $1,500,000 or more | Cannot be insured, so the minimum down payment returns to 20% |
The minimum down payment itself is tiered: 5% on a price of $500,000 or less; between $500,000 and $1,500,000, 5% on the first $500,000 and 10% on the rest. "5% down" has only ever applied to the first $500,000 — get that wrong and every number after it is wrong too.
How the premium is priced: by loan-to-value, not by price
The premium is a one-time charge calculated as a percentage of the total loan, and the band is set by your loan-to-value ratio (LTV). CMHC's published schedule for owner-occupied homeowner loans:
| Loan-to-value | Corresponding down payment | Premium (% of loan) |
|---|---|---|
| 90.01%–95% | 5%–9.99% | 4.00% |
| 90.01%–95%, non-traditional down payment source | 5%–9.99% | 4.50% |
| 85.01%–90% | 10%–14.99% | 3.10% |
| 80.01%–85% | 15%–19.99% | 2.80% |
| 80% or less | 20% or more | Not required; where a loan is insured anyway, 0.60%–2.40% |
Using the same worked example CMHC publishes: a $750,000 home with $60,000 down (8%) leaves a $690,000 mortgage in the 4.00% band, for a premium of $27,600. The premium is normally added to the mortgage rather than paid in cash — with one exception to budget for: Ontario charges 8% provincial sales tax on the premium, and that tax cannot be added to the loan. On a $27,600 premium the tax is $2,208, payable in cash at closing. Do not leave that line out of your closing budget.
Two more details: choosing a 30-year amortization, where available to first-time or new-build buyers, carries a premium surcharge within the schedule, so have the lender price your exact case; and the premium is essentially non-refundable — do not expect a pro-rated return if you sell or switch lenders early.
What the money actually buys you
First, entry: without this insurance, the legal framework does not allow a bank to lend you more than 80% of a home's value, so your minimum down payment would simply be 20%. Second, rate treatment: because the risk sits with the insurer, insured mortgages commonly price close to low-ratio loans. Third, renewal flexibility: insured status is what lets you switch lenders on a straight renewal switch without a new stress test. The fair way to judge the premium is as the ticket price for buying sooner with less saved, weighed against the cost of waiting years to reach 20% — not as a standalone fee to resent.
Three common misunderstandings
1. "CMHC insurance protects me — it pays if I can't." Exactly backwards. It covers the lender's loss when you default. After a default, the property can still be sold and shortfall and collection issues remain yours.
2. "Just under 20% down, the premium is small anyway." The premium moves in steps, not on a slide. Crossing from 19.99% down to 20% eliminates the premium entirely; crossing from 9.99% to 10% drops the rate from 4.00% to 3.10%, which on a large mortgage is thousands of dollars. Near a band edge, a slightly larger down payment has a very concrete payoff.
3. "The three insurers' prices differ a lot, so I should shop them." CMHC, Sagen and Canada Guaranty are the three providers, their frameworks are closely aligned, and which one insures your loan is normally the lender's decision, not a shelf you pick from. The variables you control are the down payment and the amortization — those are what move your premium.
My suggested order of steps
- Calculate your tiered minimum down payment first, and confirm the price is inside the insurable range, under $1,500,000.
- Have the lender price the premium for your exact LTV band, and put Ontario's 8% tax on the premium into your closing cash budget as its own line.
- If your down payment sits near a band edge — around 9% or 19%, for example — calculate precisely what a little more down saves in premium before deciding.
- If you are taking a 30-year amortization, have the lender price the premium with its surcharge included, not just the lower payment.
- Before closing, verify the premium amount and how it is added to the loan on the mortgage commitment, and have anything unclear explained line by line.
I am Ming Ren. This insurance does not protect you — but understanding its arithmetic is how you decide how much down payment you actually need to prepare.
This article is general information, not financial or legal advice. Premium rates and eligibility follow the current published schedules of CMHC, the other insurers and lenders; consult a licensed mortgage broker or your lender before acting.
Primary sources: CMHC, "Mortgage loan insurance cost" premium schedule for homeowner loans, and CMHC, "Mortgage loan insurance explained" (CMHC.ca, checked November 2026). The $750,000 price and $60,000 down payment follow CMHC's own published worked example and are not a real transaction.


