I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain answer first: in an established luxury area like Hills of St. Andrew, your money buys three things stacked together — land, a building, and a lifestyle. They behave completely differently. The building and its finishes depreciate and go out of fashion. The land's frontage, privacy and location are close to impossible to reproduce. And the lifestyle mostly rides on the land and the street. The most common mistake is reading the whole price tag as "what this house is worth" — and paying a permanent-asset price for finishes that will not last.
1. Split the price tag into three parts first
For every house, do the split in your head. The building portion — structure, kitchen, bathrooms, flooring, systems — starts aging the day you move in. Today's most fashionable design can be exactly what the next buyer calls dated in fifteen years, so price it as a consumable: good quality earns some credit, but not permanent value. The land portion — frontage, depth, shape, orientation, elevation and the street it sits on — does not age the same way. A house can be torn down and rebuilt; you cannot widen a frontage or move a lot to a quieter street. The lifestyle portion — privacy, mature tree canopy, distance from neighbours, commuting position — comes mostly from the land and the location, and no interior budget can buy it back elsewhere.
An illustrative example with invented numbers, only to show the split: two homes at the same price. On Home A, most of the money sits in a just-finished luxury renovation on an ordinary lot. On Home B, most of the money sits in the lot, and the interior is twenty years old. If you plan to stay fifteen years or more and can redo the interior to your own standard, Home B's math holds up better: the renovation money buys your own enjoyment, while the scarce land stays scarce. If you will stay only a few years and have no appetite for construction, Home A's convenience is real value to you. Neither is automatically right — what matters is knowing which of the three parts your extra money is buying.
Once you have done the split, verify the land portion on paper, not from the listing's lot-size line. Ask the seller or the listing brokerage for the survey and check that frontage, depth and shape match what you saw on site — in older areas, listed dimensions and measured dimensions disagree often enough that this is never wasted time. Then ask what restricts the land: is there an easement running across the backyard, a protected tree standing exactly where you would want to add on, enough setback room for a pool or an accessory building? None of that shows in photos, yet all of it decides how much of the land portion can actually be realized. The building portion needs the same treatment: the year and the invoice for each major renovation decide whether it has fifteen years of life left or five. Verify both sets of documents and your three-part split stops being a feeling and becomes a fact base.
2. Judge a lot by usability, not by size
Bigger is not automatically better. When I assess a lot, I work through these items one by one:
| What to check | The question to answer |
|---|---|
| Frontage and depth | How wide and how deep — this decides how a house can sit and what room is left for a future addition |
| Shape | A regular rectangle is easy to use; an irregular lot with awkward corners is not |
| Usability | How much of the area is genuinely usable flat land, and how much is steep slope or restricted area |
| Slope and drainage | Slope affects backyard use, pool feasibility and where water runs |
| Orientation | Backyard sun and usable months of the year follow directly from orientation |
| What it backs onto | Backing onto green or open space is a plus, but check for regulated areas and tree-protection requirements |
A smaller lot that is regular, private and well located is often worth more than a larger lot that is fragmented or faces a busy road. The lot sets the ceiling for what a property can be; the renovation only decides how close to that ceiling the current house gets.
3. Buying for rebuild or severance potential? Check the rules before the math
Many buyers fall for a large lot because they are picturing a future teardown-and-rebuild, or severing a piece to sell. Whether either plan works depends on rules, not on lot size. Step one: check the Town of Aurora's Zoning By-law 6000-17 — what zone the lot is in, and what uses, setbacks, height and coverage it allows. Step two: read what the Official Plan requires in this area — new buildings and newly created lots must be compatible with the existing streetscape character; Aurora's plan states plainly that the frontage and size of new lots must maintain the character of the existing street. Step three: severing land in Ontario requires consent under section 53 of the Planning Act, granted by the municipality — it is not a line you have a surveyor draw.
The order matters: get the "what is allowed" answer first, then estimate "what it would be worth." Paying today for rebuild value that has not been approved means paying for something that does not yet exist.
Three common misunderstandings
"The seller spent a fortune renovating, so the price must be justified." No. Buyers run a different calculation: purchase price plus the cost of bringing the house up to the standard they will live in today. What a renovation originally cost is not a bargaining chip; how much life it has left is.
"The bigger the lot, the harder the asset." No. Unusable slope, awkward leftover corners and a noisy arterial frontage do not turn into value just because the area is large. Usable, private and regular beats merely big.
"The lot is big, so I can sever or build whatever I want later." You cannot assume that. Zoning controls use and dimensions, the Official Plan controls streetscape compatibility, and a severance needs a statutory approval process. Until the rules are checked, so-called rebuild potential is a hypothesis — do not pay for it as if it were a fact.
If you are choosing between two luxury homes, I suggest you work in this order
- Split each price into land, building and lifestyle in writing, so you can see at a glance which part dominates.
- Score the land item by item — frontage, depth, shape, usable area, slope, orientation, backing — instead of remembering only the total lot size.
- Value renovations by remaining life: ask for the year of each major project, not just the phrase "fully renovated."
- If rebuild, addition or severance potential is part of your reason for paying, check the zoning and the Official Plan first, then confirm feasibility for that address with the Town's planning department.
- Be honest about your time horizon and appetite for work: long-term stay plus willingness to renovate means land first; short stay plus no appetite for construction means move-in ready first.
Work honestly, and do the work properly. I am Ming Ren. Before buying a home like this, understand the land portion first and negotiate the finishes second — bring the documents, and we will go through the numbers one by one.
This article is general information, not an appraisal and not legal or planning advice. For zoning, severance or addition feasibility at a specific address, confirm with the Town of Aurora planning department and an Ontario lawyer.
Primary sources: Town of Aurora Official Plan and Comprehensive Zoning By-law 6000-17 (aurora.ca); Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, s.53 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026). Example figures are illustrative only, not real transactions.
Frequently asked questions
The seller spent a fortune renovating, so the price must be justified, right?
No. Buyers run a different calculation: purchase price plus the cost of bringing the house up to the standard they will live in today. What a renovation originally cost is not a bargaining chip; how much life it has left is.
Does a bigger lot always mean a harder asset?
No. Unusable slope, awkward leftover corners and a noisy arterial frontage do not turn into value just because the area is large. Usable, private and regular beats merely big.
If the lot is big, can I sever or build whatever I want later?
You cannot assume that. Zoning controls use and dimensions, the Official Plan controls streetscape compatibility, and a severance needs a statutory approval process. Until the rules are checked, rebuild potential is a hypothesis — do not pay for it as if it were a fact.


