I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain version first: these two neighbourhoods cannot be ranked by average price, and they do not need to be. Aurora Estates, in southwest Aurora, sells large lots, low density and an estate-style setting. Hills of St. Andrew is an established, mature luxury neighbourhood on a more conventional residential street pattern. At this end of the market only a handful of homes trade in either area in a year, and one very large home — or one teardown-and-rebuild — can drag a so-called neighbourhood average sharply up or down. Ranking the two by that number is measuring with a ruler that moves. Compare the specific house instead: the lot, the condition, and the life you will actually live there.
1. Compare the lot, not the neighbourhood name
At this tier, a heavy share of the price is the land. Run the same checklist on both sides: frontage and depth, grade, orientation, mature trees, privacy, and where the lot sits within its own street. A house can be renovated; land cannot. You cannot add frontage, deepen a lot, or buy back a tree canopy that took forty years to grow.
Then check documents, not descriptions. First, zoning: look up the specific lot's zone category and any exception provisions in the Town of Aurora's zoning by-law, because they govern what you can add or alter later. Second, the Official Plan designation for that lot, read from the Town's published schedules — do not infer it from the neighbourhood's reputation. Two lots in the same neighbourhood can sit under different details. Until the lot's own paperwork is checked, any neighbourhood comparison is talk.
2. Compare condition and the true total cost
Homes at this tier span decades: older houses that have stood for years sit beside recent custom rebuilds. List price alone compares badly. Compare purchase price plus the cost to bring the home up to standard. Ask, item by item, about the age and condition of the roof, furnace, air conditioning, windows, electrical panel and plumbing — and whether a renovation was a full systems renewal or a kitchen-and-bathroom surface job. An older home that looks cheaper can overtake the other once a roof and mechanicals are replaced.
Count the carrying side too: snow, lawns, trees and a possible pool on a large estate lot are a different order of expense from a conventional street. The same budget buys more land on one side and a newer house on the other. Neither is wrong — but decide in advance where you want your money to sit.
| What to compare | Aurora Estates: focus | Hills of St. Andrew: focus |
|---|---|---|
| The lot | Frontage, depth, grade, canopy, privacy — varies a lot lot by lot | Street maturity, lot regularity, consistency of the streetscape |
| The house | Wide age range; rebuilds mixed with older homes — check every system's age | Mostly mature housing stock — check how deep past renovations went |
| The documents | Zoning, exceptions and Official Plan designation, verified address by address | The same address-by-address check — maturity is no reason to skip it |
| Daily life | Low density and quiet; driving is the default for everything | Conventional street pattern; daily routines closer to an ordinary neighbourhood |
3. Compare the life you will actually live
The real difference between the two areas lands in daily routine. How will you move? Life in both is car-based; test your actual commute route and your route to the GO station at real times rather than judging by straight-line distance. If you have children, verify schools yourself: enter the specific address in the school locators on the York Region District School Board and York Catholic District School Board websites. Attendance boundaries change; do not take anyone's word for them.
Then ask yourself three questions. How many years will I stay? Is a large yard something I will enjoy or something I will service? How many cars, and who drives children and parents where? If your answers lean toward land, quiet and a long stay, the scale tips one way. If they lean toward convenience and low upkeep, it tips the other. There is no standard answer — only fit.
Three common misunderstandings
"The neighbourhood with the higher average price is the better one, so buying there is safe." In a pocket this small, averages are moved by single properties. They are not a stable quality measure, and a neighbourhood name is no substitute for due diligence on the one house.
"Homes within the same neighbourhood are all roughly alike." The opposite is true at this tier. Grade, age and renovation depth differ sharply from house to house. Buying "the neighbourhood" instead of the property is the easiest way to buy wrong.
"The listing side's word on schools and zoning is good enough." Boundaries and zoning both change, and both have official lookups. Anything that affects resale and daily life this directly should be checked by address, once, by you — with the result kept on file.
If you are choosing between the two, do these five things in order
- Pick two or three real candidate homes on each side and put them in one table: lot dimensions, age, system ages, asking price. Ignore neighbourhood averages entirely.
- For each home, request the tax bill, any survey, renovation records and a list of system ages from the listing side.
- Verify zoning and Official Plan designation for each address on the Town of Aurora's official pages, and record the results in the table.
- If you have children, run each address through both school boards' locators and save the results with the date you checked.
- Drive your real commute from each area once, at weekday rush hour, before you decide.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are torn between the two areas, bring the documents for your candidate homes and we will compare them, one table, item by item.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. Zoning, planning designations and school boundaries are as published by the Town of Aurora and the school boards and change over time; verify for the specific address before acting.
Primary sources: Town of Aurora Official Plan and Zoning By-law 6000-17 (aurora.ca, consulted November 2026); York Region District School Board and York Catholic District School Board official school locators. This article deliberately cites no neighbourhood average prices or growth figures.
Frequently asked questions
Is the neighbourhood with the higher average price the better one, so buying there is safe?
In a pocket this small, averages are moved by single properties and are not a stable quality measure. A neighbourhood name is no substitute for due diligence on the one house.
Are homes within the same neighbourhood all roughly alike?
The opposite is true at this tier. Grade, age and renovation depth differ sharply from house to house, and buying 'the neighbourhood' instead of the property is the easiest way to buy wrong.
Is the listing side's word on schools and zoning good enough?
Boundaries and zoning both change, and both have official lookups. Anything that affects resale and daily life this directly should be checked by address, once, by you — with the result kept on file.


