I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the conclusion first: a low appraisal does not automatically lower the purchase price, and it does not automatically let the buyer walk away. At first, it changes only one thing — how much the lender is willing to lend. Everything after that depends on what your Agreement of Purchase and Sale says, whether any conditions are still open, and how many days are left before closing. This article covers only the period before closing, and what buyers and sellers can each actually do in it.
1. Work out the shortfall properly — it is not always the full difference between the two prices
A lender calculates a mortgage on the lower of the purchase price and the appraised value, then applies the approved loan-to-value ratio to that lower number. The appraiser is engaged by the lender to estimate market value at the date of the appraisal, not to negotiate a price for either side. That is a different exercise from the MPAC assessment used for property taxes, and the MPAC figure will not persuade a lender.
Many people simply subtract one price from the other, and that often overstates the extra cash needed. An example with invented, illustrative numbers only: the purchase price is $800,000 and the appraisal is $750,000, a difference of $50,000. Suppose the buyer planned a 25% down payment — $200,000 down and a $600,000 mortgage. Calculated on $750,000 at the same 75% ratio, the lender will advance at most $562,500, which is $37,500 less. To close at the original price, the buyer needs $37,500 in extra cash, for a total down payment of $237,500 — not automatically the full $50,000.
The other side of that point matters too: if the buyer was already borrowing at the maximum ratio and holds no reserve cash, that $37,500 can still stop a closing. So the first call is not to the seller demanding a price cut. It is to your mortgage broker or lender, for three numbers: the maximum mortgage on the appraised value, the total cash needed on closing day, and whether you can actually produce it. Until those numbers exist, any negotiation is guesswork.
Why appraisals come in low deserves only a sentence here: an appraisal rests mainly on completed comparable sales, and the competitive pressure on offer night, or sales that have not yet closed, may not be reflected in it. The cause can be debated, but closing problems are solved by the choices below, not by arguing about the cause.
2. Still conditional, or already firm: two completely different positions
If your agreement still contains a financing condition that genuinely covers the mortgage, and the condition period has not expired, the buyer has room to work with. Use that time to get a clear answer from the lender, and to test whether a different product, a different lender, or a restructured down payment can be approved. At the same time, tell the seller honestly, through the agents, what the appraisal and the lender have said, and discuss a price reduction, a later closing date, or another change signed by both sides. A condition is not a sentence that says "the appraisal was low, so I am out." It has to be used as the agreement requires and within its deadline, any required notice has to be delivered properly and on time, and the buyer must try honestly and in good faith to obtain the financing — not stop trying first and then rely on the condition to exit. How a condition should be used in your case is a question for your lawyer.
If the agreement is already firm, with no unsatisfied conditions left, the position is much harder: the contract price is still the contract price, the seller has no duty to reduce it because of an appraisal report, and the buyer has no unilateral right to withdraw. In practice there are three options. First, add the cash the reduced mortgage no longer covers and close at the original price. Second, ask the lender to reconsider the appraisal — if you can show that comparable sales were missed or the property information was wrong, a lender may review it, but it has no duty to change the number and no duty to accept an appraisal report you commissioned yourself. Third, ask the seller for a price change or an extension. That is pure negotiation; if the seller agrees, it only counts once a written amendment is signed. Kind words change nothing in the contract.
If you are the seller receiving a "the appraisal came in low" message, do not answer on the spot. Ask for something in writing from the lender or mortgage broker, and establish how large the gap is, how much the buyer can cover, and how much the buyer is asking you to give up or how long you are being asked to wait. You may refuse, meet the buyer partway, or agree to an extension in exchange for something of value, such as a larger deposit. Those are your commercial decisions; nobody owes anybody a concession. But run the other calculation as well: if you refuse and the buyer truly cannot close, you may not be paid immediately, and you may not be able to resell immediately either. The time and process costs are the subject of the next section.
3. If the buyer truly cannot close, the deposit and the losses are not settled automatically
Failing to close a firm agreement is a breach risk. Do not treat it lightly. The consequences usually have two layers: the deposit may be lost, and if the seller's losses exceed the deposit, the seller may claim more — for example, the difference if the home later sells for less, plus additional carrying and transaction costs. How that is finally calculated depends on the agreement, the facts, and a settlement or a court, not on an assurance an agent can give you over the phone.
Sellers should not treat the deposit as "the buyer failed to close, so it is mine tomorrow" either. In Ontario, a deposit is generally held in trust, often by the listing brokerage, as the agreement provides. Releasing it usually requires a mutual release signed by both buyer and seller, or a court direction. If one side simply says "no refund" or "it is mine," the money often cannot move. What a seller should do is have a lawyer send the notices that need sending, preserve the evidence of the buyer's default, keep further losses under control, and decide promptly whether to settle or to relist. The timing of relisting and the treatment of the deposit affect each other, so take legal advice before acting — do not relist the home in a way that confuses your legal position.
One compromise is often overlooked: an extension. A written amendment moves the closing date by days or weeks so the buyer can arrange the extra cash, an appraisal review, or a new mortgage — provided the seller's own next purchase, move, and financing can wait. An extension is not a free favour. The new deposit, who pays which costs, and what happens if the buyer still cannot close on the new date should all be written down at the same time.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"The appraisal is the market value, so the seller has to sell at the appraised value." No. An appraisal is a valuation a lender uses to control its lending risk. It limits the mortgage; it does not change the contract price. The price changes only if both sides voluntarily sign a written amendment.
"The appraisal was low, so I can walk away at any time and get my full deposit back." That is only in play if a condition in your agreement genuinely covers the situation and you use it correctly, as required and within its deadline. A firm agreement offers no such route, and refusing to close is a breach question.
"I will hire my own appraiser, get a higher number, and the bank will have to accept it." A lender follows its own appraisal process, using appraisers it engages or accepts. A report you commission is, at most, supporting material for a request to reconsider. The lender may look at it or may not use it, and there is no rule that the higher of two appraisals wins.
If a low appraisal report arrived today, work through these steps in order
- That same day, have your mortgage broker or lender recalculate on the appraised value: the maximum mortgage, the total cash due on closing, and the amount still missing. Get those three numbers confirmed in writing or by email, not as a verbal estimate.
- Open the agreement and, with your lawyer, confirm four things: whether there is a financing condition, when the condition period ends, how notice must be given, and the closing date. Those terms and dates decide how many options you have.
- If you can cover the gap in cash, secure the source of the funds first — savings, an already-approved credit arrangement, or a family gift, which a lender will often require to be documented — and only then negotiate with the seller. Do not promise first and look for the money afterwards.
- If you are asking the seller for a concession, present one concrete package: how much off the price, how long an extension, how much more deposit — and support it with the appraisal and the lender's explanation. Anything agreed goes into a signed amendment.
- If you are the seller receiving that request, verify the buyer's shortfall and ability to cover it before deciding to refuse, concede, or extend. Do not give a verbal yes, or a verbal no with no way back, before you have seen the material.
- If closing is starting to look impossible, buyers and sellers should each speak to their own lawyer immediately about the deposit, notices, and limiting losses. Do not make that first call on closing day itself.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. When an appraisal comes in low, do not panic first. Put the mortgage numbers, the contract terms, and the dates on the table, and we will work through them one by one before deciding how to negotiate.
This article is general information only, not legal advice and not mortgage advice. The conditions in your agreement, your mortgage approval, and the timeline of your case can change the conclusion. Consult an Ontario lawyer and your mortgage professional before acting.
Primary sources: mortgage and loan-to-value guidance published on canada.ca by the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) and the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC); public guidance of the Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO) and the Law Society of Ontario (LSO) on Agreements of Purchase and Sale, how deposits are held and released, and the consequences of breach (consulted November 2026). The $800,000, $750,000, and 25% figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
The appraisal is the market value, so does the seller have to sell at the appraised value?
No. An appraisal is a valuation a lender uses to control its lending risk. It limits the mortgage; it does not change the contract price, which changes only if both sides voluntarily sign a written amendment.
The appraisal was low, so can I walk away at any time and get my full deposit back?
That is only in play if a condition in your agreement genuinely covers the situation and you use it correctly, as required and within its deadline. A firm agreement offers no such route, and refusing to close is a breach question.
Can I hire my own appraiser, get a higher number, and make the bank accept it?
A lender follows its own appraisal process, using appraisers it engages or accepts. A report you commission is, at most, supporting material for a request to reconsider, and there is no rule that the higher of two appraisals wins.


