Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

When the Appraisal Comes In Low on a Firm Offer in Ontario, Who Pays the Gap?

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the plain conclusion first: a lender does not fund your mortgage on the price you negotiated alone. It sizes the loan on the lower of the purchase price and the appraised value. If your offer is already firm, with no financing condition to fall back on, the shortfall created by a low appraisal is, in principle, cash you must find yourself. If you cannot find it and cannot close, you risk your deposit and a further claim from the seller — a low appraisal is not an automatic way out of the contract.

First: which number the lender actually uses

A mortgage is not based on the contract price alone. The lender needs to confirm what the home is worth in its own assessment, and it will usually order an independent appraisal that produces an appraised value. For an insured mortgage, CMHC's lending value is the lower of market value and purchase price, and conventional lenders size loans on the same logic: the loan follows the lower number, and the lender does not fund the part of your price that sits above the value.

One related rule matters for your down payment. If you put down less than 20%, you generally need mortgage default insurance. Under CMHC's current rules, insurance is only possible on homes priced under $1.5 million, the minimum down payment is 5% of the first $500,000 plus 10% of the portion above that, and the maximum loan-to-value can reach 95%. When the appraisal drops, the base for the loan drops with it — and buyers with the thinnest down payments have the smallest cushion and feel it first.

Second: how to calculate the cash you now need

Do not guess the shortfall. Work it out in three steps:

Step Calculation
Set the base Take the lower of the purchase price and the appraised value
Find the loan ceiling Base × your approved loan-to-value ratio
Find your cash Purchase price − loan ceiling = cash needed to close

Here is an illustrative example I made up, with numbers chosen only to show the math: the price is $880,000 and you planned 20% down, or $176,000, with a $704,000 mortgage. The appraisal comes in at $820,000. The lender will lend at most 80% of $820,000, which is $656,000, so the cash you need to close becomes $880,000 − $656,000 = $224,000 — $48,000 more than planned. Note that the extra cash is not the full $60,000 gap; it is 80% of it, because the other 20% was always your own down payment. How much extra you need depends on your loan-to-value ratio: the higher the ratio, the closer the extra cash gets to the full gap.

Why does an appraisal come in low at all? An appraiser works mainly from recent, real comparable sales — not from how badly you wanted the home on offer night. A bidding war that pushes the price above the comparables, a market that cools after you sign, or a unusual property with few recent comparable sales nearby can all leave the appraisal behind the price. That is not the appraiser working against you; the appraiser's yardstick and a competing buyer's yardstick are simply different.

So before you compete for a home, ask yourself one question: if the appraisal came in 5% below my price, do I have that cash available right now? Remember, too, that land transfer tax, legal fees and other closing costs still have to be paid on top of that cash, so do not count that money toward the gap. If you cannot answer yes, think very carefully before waiving every condition.

Third: your offer is firm — what is actually left

Be clear about where you stand. Firm means no conditions. A low appraisal, on its own, is not a legal reason to walk away. The seller has no obligation to cut the price because of your lender's appraisal, and you cannot change the contract price on your own.

The remaining options, in realistic order, are these. First, cover the gap in cash — the most direct route, if the money is genuinely available and you still have closing costs and a reserve left after using it. Second, ask for a review through your lender: if you can supply recent, genuinely comparable sales the appraiser missed, you can request a reconsideration of value, but the lender and the appraiser decide, and a change is not guaranteed. Third, ask your mortgage broker whether a different lender or a new appraisal is realistic — the cost is time, and everything must finish before the closing date. Fourth, ask the seller to consider a price reduction or an extension; that is pure negotiation, and the seller may refuse. Expensive short-term borrowing to plug the gap is a last resort, and you should not touch it until you have calculated its full cost.

The moves that truly protect you happen before you sign: keeping a financing condition, having your mortgage broker test your price against comparable sales in advance, and holding a cash reserve for a possible gap. Do those three things first, then decide whether going firm makes sense.

Three common misunderstandings

Misunderstanding 1: "I was pre-approved, so the mortgage is approved." No. A pre-approval looks at you and an assumed price. Final approval also looks at this specific property, including its appraised value. A pre-approval is not a promise to fund your purchase price.

Misunderstanding 2: "If the appraisal is low, the contract price automatically drops." It does not. The contract price stays exactly where it is unless both sides agree in writing to change it. What changes is how much the lender will lend, and the difference lands on your cash.

Misunderstanding 3: "The extra cash always equals the appraisal gap." Not necessarily. In the example above, at 80% financing the extra cash was 80% of the gap. Run your own loan-to-value ratio through the math — do not frighten yourself, and do not underestimate it either.

If you are about to offer, or have just received a low appraisal, do this in order

  1. Do the math first: take the lower of price and appraised value, apply your loan-to-value ratio, and work out exactly how much cash closing now requires and how far that is from your plan.
  2. Call your mortgage broker right away and confirm whether this is a value problem, an income problem, or a property problem — the fix is completely different for each.
  3. If you have the cash to cover the gap, confirm that your closing costs and emergency reserve survive after you use it; do not empty yourself out just to close.
  4. If you believe the appraisal missed comparable sales, organize those sales by address, date and price, and submit them formally through your lender — do not argue with the appraiser yourself.
  5. If you have not offered yet, settle the financing-condition question and the size of appraisal gap you can absorb with your agent and mortgage broker before you sign. If you are already firm and cannot cover the gap, speak to your real estate lawyer immediately, not on the closing date.

I am Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron. Before you offer on a home, work through the appraisal math first — and let us go through the numbers, one by one.


This article is general information only, not legal, mortgage or financial advice. Loan amounts, insurance eligibility and down payment requirements vary by lender, product and personal circumstances. Consult your mortgage broker and an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary sources: CMHC mortgage loan insurance and lending value guidance (lower of market value and purchase price), and CMHC minimum down payment and $1.5 million insurance-cap guidance (CMHC website, reviewed November 2026). The $880,000 and $820,000 figures are illustrative, not a real transaction.

Frequently asked questions

I was pre-approved, so is the mortgage approved?

No. A pre-approval looks at you and an assumed price. Final approval also looks at this specific property, including its appraised value; a pre-approval is not a promise to fund your purchase price.

If the appraisal is low, does the contract price automatically drop?

It does not. The contract price stays exactly where it is unless both sides agree in writing to change it. What changes is how much the lender will lend, and the difference lands on your cash.

Does the extra cash always equal the appraisal gap?

Not necessarily. In the article's example, at 80% financing the extra cash was 80% of the gap. Run your own loan-to-value ratio through the math.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation