I'm Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Let me put the conclusion first: I generally recommend title insurance, but you have to buy the right one. The policy that actually protects you is the owner's policy with your name on it. The one your bank requires protects the bank — it has nothing to do with you. Confuse the two, and you can spend the money while the protection sits with someone else.
This article covers three things: what title insurance actually covers, how the two policies differ, and how it is different from a lawyer's opinion on title.
First: it covers hidden problems in the title, not the house itself
Title insurance does not cover leaks, foundations, or how comfortable the house is to live in. It covers whether the title to the property is legally clean — the history problems that a walkthrough and a surface review of the documents cannot turn up.
In general terms, an owner's policy typically covers risks such as:
- Title fraud and forged documents: someone forges paperwork to transfer the home out of the real owner's name, or to mortgage it, and the registered owner is the victim.
- Undiscoverable debts and liens: certain debts or unregistered interests left behind by a previous owner that a closing search did not reveal, which later surface against the property.
- Encroachments and boundary problems: a garage or fence sitting on the neighbour's land, or a neighbour's structure sitting on yours — the kind of thing an up-to-date survey would normally reveal.
- Leftover problems from unpermitted work: a previous owner built without permits, the municipality later issues an order, and the responsibility lands on the current owner.
- Errors in the registered records: mistakes in historical registrations or survey records that affect your legal interest in the property.
On the other side, it does not cover problems you already knew about when you bought, it does not cover the physical condition of the house, and it does not cover trouble caused by work you do yourself after moving in. Every insurer's wording and exclusions differ somewhat, so the policy you are actually issued is what governs.
One more basic point: in Ontario, title insurance is a class of insurance regulated under the Insurance Act. It can only be issued by a licensed insurer, and insurers are regulated by the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA). It is not a fee a lawyer invented — it is a real insurance contract.
Second: two policies, and they do not protect the same person
When people say "title insurance" at closing, they are often talking about two different policies at once. Keeping them apart matters:
| Owner's Policy | Lender's Policy | |
|---|---|---|
| Who it protects | You, the registered owner | Only the mortgage lender |
| How long it lasts | As long as you own the property | While the mortgage is outstanding; coverage shrinks as the loan balance falls |
| Who requires it | Nobody — it is your own decision | The lender usually requires it as a condition of the loan |
| How the premium is paid | One-time payment, no annual fee | One-time payment, usually handled at closing |
The most important row is the first one: a lender's policy pays out to the bank. If a title problem appears, the bank's policy will not pay you a cent. So "we already bought title insurance at closing" does not automatically mean you are covered — first check whose name is on the policy.
Here is an example I made up, with illustrative numbers only: say a home closes at $900,000 (illustrative figure), and the closing package contains only a lender's policy. Two years later, an unpaid debt left by a previous owner surfaces against the property. The bank's policy deals with the bank's lending risk; your own loss is your own problem. If an owner's policy had been arranged at the same time, losses of this kind that fall within coverage are the insurer's to handle under the policy.
Third: it is not the same thing as your lawyer's opinion on title
Under the older approach, after completing the title searches, your lawyer would give an opinion on title — in effect: based on the records and documents I searched, title to this property is clean. That opinion has two built-in limits. First, it rests only on what could be searched at closing; forgery and hidden defects that no search could reveal fall outside it. Second, if something inside the opinion turns out to be wrong, your route is a claim against the lawyer — slow, and hard to prove.
Title insurance changes the approach: the lawyer still does the searches and still reviews everything, but the risk of what searches cannot find is packaged and transferred to an insurer. If a covered problem appears, you claim under the policy and the insurer handles and pays it — you do not first have to prove whose fault it was. The Law Society of Ontario's practice guidance for real estate transactions also expects lawyers to explain the different approaches to protecting title to their clients, including title insurance as an option, so the client decides with full information.
So neither replaces the other: the lawyer's searches and opinion are the foundation, and insurance is an added layer on top of that foundation that transfers risk. Skipping the lawyer and only buying insurance, or relying only on the lawyer's opinion and carrying the undiscoverable risks yourself, each does only half the job.
Three common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "We bought title insurance at closing, so the insurer handles anything that goes wrong." First check which policy it is. If it is only a lender's policy, the insurer is looking after the bank. Then check whether the problem is even a covered risk: the policy covers listed title risks, not the physical condition of the house and not defects you already knew about.
Misunderstanding 2: "With title insurance, I don't need a survey or a lawyer's title search." No. The insurer's coverage is premised on your lawyer having done the searches properly. Insurance carries the risks that proper searches still cannot find; it does not let you skip the searches. Whether you also need a new survey depends on your specific plans for the boundaries — if you are unsure, ask your lawyer.
Misunderstanding 3: "Title insurance is something you pay for every year." It is not. It is a one-time premium paid at closing, and an owner's policy stays in force for as long as you own that property — no annual fee, no renewal. A new home or a new transaction means a new policy; the old one does not follow you to the next property.
Before closing, I suggest confirming these in order
- Ask your lawyer one question: is the title insurance being arranged an owner's policy, a lender's policy, or both? Listen carefully to the answer.
- Confirm the insured name on the owner's policy is yours, and that the coverage amount matches the purchase price.
- When you receive the policy, keep the coverage and exclusions pages. Check in particular that fraud, encroachments, and unpermitted work are addressed.
- If the seller or your lawyer mentions known renovations or a boundary dispute, raise it early — known problems are generally not covered, and staying silent only hurts you in the end.
- Store the original policy with your closing documents, long term. If a problem ever appears, this policy is what a claim is made under; hunting for it years later puts you on the back foot.
- If a problem appears, report it to the insurer first, then discuss next steps with your lawyer. Do not sign any settlement with the other side on your own first.
Work honestly, and do solid work. I'm Ming Ren. Read your closing documents one page at a time — knowing where the money goes and who is actually protected is worth more than anything else in the pile.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Coverage and exclusions are governed by the wording of the policy issued by your insurer, and the details of your transaction affect the conclusion. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Insurance Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. I.8 (Ontario e-Laws); Law Society of Ontario real estate practice guidance; FSRA's regulatory framework for licensed insurers in Ontario. The $900,000 figure is an illustrative number I made up, not a real transaction or quote.
Frequently asked questions
We bought title insurance at closing, so the insurer handles anything that goes wrong?
First check which policy it is. If it is only a lender's policy, the insurer is looking after the bank. Then check whether the problem is even a covered risk: the policy covers listed title risks, not the physical condition of the house and not defects you already knew about.
With title insurance, I don't need a survey or a lawyer's title search?
No. The insurer's coverage is premised on your lawyer having done the searches properly. Insurance carries the risks that proper searches still cannot find; it does not let you skip the searches. Whether you also need a new survey depends on your specific plans for the boundaries.
Is title insurance something you pay for every year?
It is not. It is a one-time premium paid at closing, and an owner's policy stays in force for as long as you own that property — no annual fee, no renewal. A new home or a new transaction means a new policy; the old one does not follow you to the next property.


