I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The conclusion first: short-term rental compliance in Canada is no longer just a municipal fine issue. For tax years after 2023, s.67.7 of the Income Tax Act ties expense deductions to local compliance: for every day of the year a short-term rental was non-compliant, a proportional slice of the year's deductions is denied. The income is fully taxed; the expenses are discounted. That is a far more expensive penalty than any fine.
First: "non-compliant" has exactly two doors
Section 67.7's definition is narrow and looks only at the government layer:
- The location does not permit short-term rentals at all. If the province or municipality does not allow a short-term rental to operate at that location, operating one there is non-compliant.
- Registration, licensing or permit requirements are not all met. Where the locality requires registration, a licence or a permit, any period in which the requirements are not fully satisfied is non-compliant.
Notice what the definition ignores: condominium corporation rules and platform policies are not part of the s.67.7 test; it watches government permission only. The reverse also holds — a registration that takes effect a day late makes that day a non-compliant day. The count is by days, with no "close enough."
The definition of short-term rental itself matters just as much: a residential property rented or offered for rent for a period of less than 90 consecutive days. "Offered for rent" means listed days count, and empty-but-listed days can enter the formula's denominator.
Second: the formula A × B ÷ C cuts a proportion, not the whole
The denied amount — the "non-compliant amount" — is computed under s.67.7(1):
Non-compliant amount = A × B ÷ C
| Letter | Meaning |
|---|---|
| A | Total amounts that would be deductible for the year in respect of the property's use as a short-term rental, if s.67.7 did not exist |
| B | Days in the year the property was a non-compliant short-term rental |
| C | Days in the year the property was a short-term rental |
Under s.67.7(2), the non-compliant amount simply cannot be deducted in computing income. The remainder goes back into the ordinary deduction rules — it is not automatically allowed, merely no longer cut by this section.
An invented calculation: a property is a short-term rental for 200 days in the year, of which the first 120 days ran before its registration took effect; deductible short-term rental expenses for the year total $18,000. Non-compliant amount = $18,000 × 120 ÷ 200 = $10,800. Only $7,200 of expenses survives into the ordinary rules; $10,800 evaporates — even if guests actually stayed only a handful of those 120 days. The formula counts days, not revenue, which is what makes it bite.
One tail worth knowing: s.67.7(4) lets the Minister reassess for this section's purposes without the usual limitation periods standing in the way. A non-compliant year's deductions do not become safe simply because several quiet years pass.
Third: the 2024 transition relief is over — do not plan around it
Section 67.7(3) offered one-time relief: a short-term rental that complied with all registration, licensing and permit requirements by December 31, 2024 was deemed compliant for the whole 2024 tax year. That relief belongs to 2024 alone. From 2025 onward there is no year-end cure that wipes the slate; compliance runs from the day it is achieved, counted day by day.
For operating landlords, the sequence now reverses: it used to be list first and register when convenient. Now, every day before a registration takes effect is proportionally burning the whole year's expense deductions. Renewals are the same — a licence that lapses for a few days puts those days straight into B.
Local rules vary enormously. Some cities allow short-term rentals only in a principal residence, some zones prohibit them outright, and some addresses need both provincial registration and a municipal licence stacked together. Whether a given property complies is answered by that municipality's rules in force at the time — never by a platform or a fellow host saying "everyone does it this way."
| Situation | Deduction result |
|---|---|
| Compliant all year | s.67.7 does not cut; ordinary rules apply |
| Registration takes effect mid-year | Pre-effect days go into B; cut by A×B÷C |
| Operating where short-term rentals are prohibited | Potentially all short-term days in B — near-total denial |
| Brought into compliance by Dec 31, 2024 | Deemed compliant for 2024 only (transition relief) |
| Brought into compliance in 2025 or later | No whole-year relief; counted by days |
How to keep a day-count that survives a CRA question
Every s.67.7 dispute ends at the evidence: who proves B and C? The landlord's own day ledger has to reconcile with third-party records — platform booking calendars, listing on-and-off dates, the effective-date documents for registrations and licences, dated cleaning and repair invoices. Assembled together, those make a complete annual day file. A self-prepared spreadsheet alone invites CRA to recompute from platform data, and platform data usually reads "offered for rent" more broadly than the landlord did.
Plan for the mixed year as well: a property short-term rented for part of the year, long-term rented or personally used for the rest. C counts only short-term days, and A captures only expenses attributable to the short-term use — the Act gives no ready-made allocation for shared costs, so the accountant must adopt a reasonable split and document it. Classifying expenses monthly as they arise is what makes that year-end split defensible; a single annual lump of utilities, insurance and property tax cannot be untangled by anyone.
Three common misunderstandings
One: "Non-compliance means a city fine at worst; deductions are separate." Section 67.7 exists precisely to close that gap. Beyond any fine, deductions are denied pro rata by days — usually the larger amount by far.
Two: "No guests stayed during the unregistered days, so they don't count." B counts days the property was a non-compliant short-term rental, and the definition includes being offered for rent. No guests does not mean outside the formula.
Three: "Get the licence by year-end and the whole year is fine." That was the expired 2024 transition rule, for that year only. After 2024 the count is by days, and the effective date is the dividing line.
If you run, or plan to run, a short-term rental, in this order
- Check the current rules for the property's municipality first: permitted at all, how many layers of registration or licensing, principal-residence limits — and keep a copy of the rules as they stood.
- List only after every registration and licence is in effect; if you are already operating, isolate the pre-effect days in your records.
- Keep a day ledger: total short-term days (C) and non-compliant days (B) tracked separately, matched to the expense total (A) for the same tax year.
- Diary licence renewals well ahead of expiry; never allow a gap day to exist.
- Before filing, have your accountant compute the non-compliant amount under s.67.7 and present it separately — do not deduct the full year's expenses and wait for CRA to do the cutting.
In the short-term rental business, guard the compliant days and the deductions guard themselves. I am Ming Ren; bring the licence dates and the day counts and we will run the formula before the return is filed.
This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. Individual facts, documents and timelines can change the conclusion; consult an Ontario lawyer or the relevant professional before acting.
Primary sources: Income Tax Act, s.67.7; CRA, Changes to rules for eligible deductions from short-term rental income and Guide T4036 (canada.ca / Justice Laws) (accessed November 2026). All persons, figures and examples in this article are invented and illustrative only.


