Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

Sell Now and Move Up, or Wait? Judge the Move by One Number: The Gap

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the conclusion first: when you move up, do not try to guess "what will my place sell for" and "will the bigger place go up or down" as two separate questions. You are a seller and a buyer at the same time, in the same market, and the two prices move together. What actually decides whether the move costs you more or less is the gap between the two homes. If the gap works in your favour, the mortgage works, and you keep enough cash in reserve, you can move. If any one of those three clearly fails, wait — and be able to say, in numbers, what you are waiting for.

First: turn two markets into one number

Most people get stuck because they split the decision into two questions nobody can answer: when will my home sell at its peak, and when will the target home bottom out? Those two moments almost never arrive together, and the prices are tied together anyway. When the market rises, you sell high and buy high. When it falls, you sell low and buy low. Looking at either side alone gives you the wrong answer.

The right approach is to calculate one number: the price of the home you want − the price of the home you have = the gap. What you actually pay for "more house" is that gap, plus transaction costs, minus the equity you can pull out of your current home.

An illustrative example (these are invented numbers to show the arithmetic, not market data): say your current home is worth $800,000 and the home you want is $1,500,000. The gap is $700,000. Now suppose both rise 10%: yours sells for $880,000, the target rises to $1,650,000, and the gap widens to $770,000 — waiting made the move $70,000 more expensive. Now suppose both fall 10%: yours sells for $720,000, the target drops to $1,350,000, and the gap shrinks to $630,000 — the market "fell," yet moving up got $70,000 cheaper.

So the question is never "will the market go up or down." It is "is the gap widening or narrowing, and can I live with where it lands?" In practice: take recent real sold prices for homes like yours and for the type and neighbourhood you are targeting, work out today's gap, then stress it — if both sides moved 10% either way, what gap would you face, and would you still accept it? If yes, there is no reason to put your family's life on hold waiting for a turning point nobody can call.

One more detail on the arithmetic: use sold prices on both sides, never asking prices. An asking price is a seller's wish — some are set high, some low — and a gap built on wishes is fiction. What your home is worth comes from what similar homes in your community actually sold for recently; the same applies to the target home. Only when both numbers rest on real transactions is the gap trustworthy, and only then is the decision built on solid ground rather than sand.

Second: a good gap still has to pass three checks

The gap is only the entry ticket. If these three checks fail, pause even if the gap looks attractive.

Check one: the mortgage — approval and carrying cost. In Canada, lenders must qualify you under the mortgage stress test: you have to show you can afford payments at the higher of your negotiated contract rate plus 2%, or 5.25% (this is the standard published by the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, applied by banks and other federally regulated lenders under OSFI's Guideline B-20). A move-up usually means a bigger mortgage, so have your mortgage professional calculate the new payment at that qualifying rate, add property tax, heating and other carrying costs, and look honestly at the share of your gross household income. Note that the stress test uses the qualifying rate, not the rate you will actually pay — do not comfort yourself with the lower real payment.

Check two: transaction costs, spread over how long you will stay. Moving up is two transactions. Selling costs commission and legal fees. Buying costs Ontario land transfer tax (plus the City of Toronto's additional municipal land transfer tax if the home is in Toronto), legal fees, inspection and moving costs. Added up, this is real money, and it is spent again every time you move. If you expect to stay in the new home for many years, the cost per year is modest. If work, school or family changes might move you again in two or three years, do the math carefully — waiting and doing it once, properly, is often cheaper.

Check three: sequence and cash buffer. Buy first and you lock in the home you love, but if the old home sells late you may carry two mortgages for a while, possibly with bridge financing in between. Sell first and your budget is certain, but you may need a short rental if the right home does not appear in time. Either order can work. What cannot be skipped is the buffer: on top of the down payment and closing costs, keep enough cash to cover several months of household expenses. Do not pour every dollar of the sale into the new down payment. If the buffer is not there, lower the target price a notch — or wait until you have built it.

Common misunderstandings

"I'll wait until my home gets back to what it was once worth." When your home climbs back, the bigger home you want has usually climbed too. The gap has not shrunk — it may have grown. Waiting to "break even" often means paying more to move up.

"The market is weak, so moving up now must be a bad deal." That is true for a pure seller. For a move-up buyer it is not necessarily so: when both sides fall together, the gap can narrow, and the extra money you actually pay can be less. Judge by the gap, not by one side of the market.

"I'll wait for rates to drop a bit more first." Rates affect your payment and how much you can qualify for; they do not directly set the gap. Betting the gap and your family's plans on an uncertain small rate move rarely pays. If you wait, wait for one of your own three checks to improve — the buffer built up, the mortgage qualifying — not for a headline.

Action checklist

  1. Using recent real sold prices, estimate today's value of your current home and of the type of home you want, and calculate today's gap.
  2. Stress-test the gap: move both prices up 10% and down 10% and see what gap you would face in each case — and whether you would accept it.
  3. List the transaction costs item by item: selling commission and legal fees; Ontario land transfer tax on the purchase (plus Toronto's municipal tax if applicable); legal, inspection and moving costs. Total them.
  4. Have a mortgage professional run the new mortgage at the stress-test qualifying rate (the higher of contract rate + 2% or 5.25%) and confirm you qualify and can carry it.
  5. Choose your sequence — buy first or sell first. If buying first, ask about bridge financing terms in advance and plan cash for the old home selling a month or two late.
  6. Calculate your buffer: after the down payment and closing costs, keep cash covering several months of household expenses. If it falls short, lower the target price or postpone.
  7. Decide your time horizon: if you expect to stay only a short time, divide the transaction costs by the years you will stay before deciding whether to wait and do it once.

Moving up is not a bet on the market. It is aligning your family's housing with a large amount of money. Work out the gap, pass the three checks, and the answer usually makes itself.

Honest work, done properly. — Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron


This article is general information only and is not legal, tax or mortgage advice; for approval and tax questions, consult a licensed mortgage professional, lawyer or accountant.

Primary sources checked: Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (canada.ca) mortgage stress test and Mortgage Qualifier Tool; OSFI Guideline B-20; Ontario Ministry of Finance (ontario.ca) land transfer tax rates. All prices in the worked example are the author's illustrative numbers, not market statistics.

Frequently asked questions

I'll wait until my home gets back to what it was once worth?

When your home climbs back, the bigger home you want has usually climbed too. The gap has not shrunk — it may have grown. Waiting to break even often means a more expensive move.

The market is weak, so is moving up now a bad deal?

That is true for a pure seller. For a move-up buyer it is not necessarily so: when both sides fall together, the gap can narrow, and the extra money you actually pay can be less. Judge by the gap, not by one side of the market.

I'll wait for rates to drop a bit more first?

Rates affect your payment and how much you can qualify for; they do not directly set the gap. Betting the gap and your family's plans on an uncertain small rate move rarely pays; wait instead for whichever of your own readiness tests has not passed yet to improve.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation