I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion: Schedule B looks like a stack of standard clauses nobody reads, but legally it is indistinguishable from the body of the agreement. And there is a sharper point: adding a Schedule B at acceptance that the other side never signed can mean the "acceptance" never legally happened — it is a counter-offer, and if it is not accepted, there is no contract at all. A 2024 Ontario court decision says exactly that.
1. What the court actually decided
In Ali v. Patel, 2024 ONSC 3505, the buyer made an unconditional offer with the usual Schedule A. When the sellers accepted, they noted on the first page that the agreement now included a new Schedule B, attached it, and asked the buyer to initial both the change and the schedule. The buyer never did, never delivered the $50,000 deposit, and the next day said they could not proceed for family reasons, sending a mutual release. The sellers relisted, sold a week later for $25,000 less, and sued for the deposit.
The sellers lost. The court held that adding Schedule B and requiring the buyer's initials made the sellers' response a counter-offer, not an acceptance. The buyer never accepted that counter-offer, so no binding agreement of purchase and sale ever existed — and with no agreement, there was no deposit to claim. The sellers absorbed the $25,000 shortfall plus their own legal costs and part of the buyer's.
Note what was in that Schedule B: mostly routine machinery — the definition of a banking day, what happens if banks and registry offices are closed on closing, the timing and form of the deposit, where keys would be left. However "standard" the content, it was still a document added at acceptance that the buyer had never agreed to.
2. Why adding a schedule can erase the contract
A contract needs a meeting of the minds on all essential terms. Offer, acceptance and counter-offer are three different acts: an acceptance must take the offer as it stands. Add anything in the act of "accepting" — a schedule, a sentence, a changed term — and in law you have rejected the offer and made a new one. The original offer dies, and no contract exists until the other side accepts the new one.
So the question is never whether Schedule B's contents are important. It is whether both sides actually agreed to it. The practical tests: was the schedule included when the offer was made; did both parties sign or initial the schedule and every change; and is the final, complete version in each side's hands identical? Fail any one and the existence of the contract itself can become the dispute — and disputes of that kind end in litigation, at the cost the sellers paid in this case.
Buyers should hear the other edge of the blade: this decision is not a free exit card. If the schedule was included from the start, or you signed the confirmation, the other side may well establish that a contract was formed — and then walking away is a breach, with the deposit and any price shortfall in play.
3. The contents of Schedule B still have to be read
Even when the process is clean, Schedule B clauses are not filler. A brokerage's standard Schedule B usually carries the execution machinery of the deal: when and how the deposit is paid and to whom; definitions of banking days and electronic funds transfer; how closing documents are exchanged; how keys and remotes are handed over. A seller-drafted schedule can carry heavier cargo: as-is statements, limits on included items, and allocations of responsibility for tenants or a basement unit.
Read every clause with three questions: what obligation does this put on me; does it conflict with the agreement body or Schedule A, and if so, which governs; and what does it change if I default — or if they do? If you cannot answer a clause, do not sign it. Send it to your lawyer first.
An invented example: the schedule requires the deposit by bank draft to the seller's lawyer within 24 hours of acceptance. You sign, then pay by ordinary transfer a day late — and the other side now argues you are in breach and the deal is off, with your deposit as the bargaining chip. That is how paper clauses become real money.
Three common misunderstandings
"Schedule B is all standard; signing it changes nothing." In this case a routine Schedule B decided whether a contract existed at all. Standard does not mean consequence-free.
"They signed and sent the agreement back, so we have a deal." Compare the returned version with yours: new schedules, changes, requests for your initials. If the versions differ, the deal may exist only in your head.
"I am the buyer; the schedule problem is the seller's risk." The rule cuts both ways. Add terms on a counter-offer that are never accepted, and the home you think you locked up is not locked up at all.
If you are signing an offer, do this in order
- Before submitting or accepting, list the complete final package — agreement body, Schedule A, Schedule B, every attachment — and reconcile page counts and versions.
- Treat any schedule added or changed by either side as a new offer: until the other side signs in confirmation, do not announce a deal or spend money on next steps.
- Initial every schedule and every handwritten change, and keep a complete, identical copy of the final version.
- Read Schedule B clause by clause — deposit timing and method, delivery of documents, as-is statements — and send anything unclear to your lawyer before signing.
- If the other side changed anything at acceptance, stop and verify; do not initial under irrevocable-deadline pressure.
Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron. In contract work, aligned versions and complete signatures come before price — they decide whether a deal exists at all.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Whether a contract was formed depends on the full documents and signing history; consult an Ontario lawyer.
Primary source: Ali v. Patel, 2024 ONSC 3505 (CanLII) and published case commentary (checked November 2026). The deposit-timing example is invented; the case facts are as publicly reported.
Frequently asked questions
Is Schedule B all standard, so signing it changes nothing?
No. In the case discussed, a routine Schedule B decided whether a contract existed at all; standard does not mean consequence-free.
If they signed and sent the agreement back, do we have a deal?
Not necessarily. Compare the returned version with yours for new schedules, changes, or requests for your initials; if the versions differ, the deal may exist only in your head.
As a buyer, is the schedule problem only the seller's risk?
No. The rule cuts both ways; add terms on a counter-offer that are never accepted, and the home you think you locked up is not locked up at all.


