Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Commercial Real Estate & Leasing

Your Landlord Promised Not to Lease to a Competitor. Is That Worth Anything in Ontario?

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Commercial Real Estate & Leasing · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: an exclusivity clause is worth what its wording is worth, not what the landlord sounded like at the negotiating table. Four things have to be pinned down in writing — how a "competitor" is identified, what land the promise covers, which existing tenants are carved out, and what you actually get if the landlord breaches. Miss one, and on the day a dispute arrives the clause is close to decoration.

This article covers three things: what a usable clause must say, the federal Competition Act line that appeared at the end of 2024, and the practical steps that decide whether the promise holds up.

1. A usable exclusivity clause pins down four things

An exclusivity clause is a promise about the landlord's future leasing: within an agreed area, the landlord will not lease to a business that competes for your customers. It restricts the landlord; it does not guarantee your sales. So the negotiation is not about whether the clause exists, but about these four points:

Must be pinned down If it is left vague Stronger drafting direction
Definition of a competitor "Similar business" means whatever each side says it means List specific goods or services, or set a threshold based on the share of the other tenant's selling area or sales devoted to them
Land covered "The building" leaves the pad site next door outside the promise Name the whole shopping centre and attach a site plan marking the area
Existing-tenant carve-outs You learn after moving in that a similar store was exempted all along Require the landlord to list every carved-out tenant, by name, in a schedule
Remedy for breach "The landlord shall not breach" — and then nothing State the consequence: rent reduction, a right to terminate, injunctive relief, plus notice and cure periods

One point on the definition deserves emphasis. A bare category word is the weakest drafting there is. When a dispute comes, the question is always "does that store count as a competitor?" — is a supermarket that happens to sell coffee a competitor of a coffee shop? Without a percentage threshold or an itemized list, there is no ready answer, only a legal bill. A simple test before signing: hand the clause to someone who knows nothing about your business and ask whether a described store next door would breach it. If they cannot answer, the clause is not finished.

2. Since late 2024 there is also a federal line: Competition Act s.90.1

Many tenants on long leases have not absorbed this yet. Section 90.1 of Canada's Competition Act used to reach only agreements between competitors. Since December 15, 2024, it also reaches agreements between non-competitors where the Competition Tribunal finds that a significant purpose of the arrangement is to prevent or lessen competition in a market. A landlord and tenant are not competitors, yet they sign exactly this kind of restriction — which is why lease exclusivity is squarely in scope.

What does that mean for you? Not that exclusivity clauses can no longer be signed. It means the broader, longer and less justified the exclusivity, the more exposure it carries. The Competition Bureau's guidance on property controls points in a consistent direction: an exclusivity that lets a new business enter a market and invest with confidence is easier to defend; one that sweeps in a wide territory, runs for a very long time and keeps an entire category out is the kind that draws scrutiny. Since June 20, 2025, private parties can also apply to the Tribunal in respect of these agreements, and both landlord and tenant can find themselves on the receiving end.

The practical takeaway is modest: ask for exclusivity that is precise — a narrow category, a term tied to your lease and your payback period, and only the land that actually affects you. An oversized exclusivity used to be a negotiating trophy; now it carries compliance risk as well.

3. Whether the promise holds is decided by everyday evidence

A well-drafted clause is not the end of the work. Most exclusivity disputes are lost on evidence, not on law:

  • When the landlord leases to a business that overlaps with yours, record the dates, the products and the proof. Memory is not evidence.
  • If you suspect a breach, notify the landlord in writing the way the lease requires and keep proof of delivery before reaching for remedies. Stopping rent on your own usually puts you in breach first.
  • On renewal or assignment, re-read the clause. Leases change hands and landlords change; confirm in the documents that the exclusivity still follows, rather than assuming it does.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"The landlord promised verbally, which is almost as good as having it in the lease." It is not close. An oral promise has to be proven — what was said, and what it meant. A defined clause in the lease is a standard you can measure conduct against directly.

"An exclusivity clause guarantees my store will make money." No. It only limits the landlord's leasing within the agreed area. It does not stop customers from shopping elsewhere, and it does not protect you if the centre declines or an anchor leaves — that is what a co-tenancy clause is for, which is a different clause altogether.

"The wider the exclusivity, the safer I am." An overbroad clause has two problems: it invites arguments about reasonableness when enforced, and since late 2024 it also sits closer to the s.90.1 line. Precise and sufficient beats sweeping.

Before you sign, do these five things in order

  1. Write your own list first: the specific goods or services you actually fear, and how much overlap counts as competition. Test the clause's definition against that list.
  2. Get the landlord's current tenant list and carve-out list, and check name by name for overlap with your business. Who is exempted should be in writing.
  3. Put the covered area on a site plan: this building only, or the whole centre. Sign only once the boundary is drawn.
  4. Negotiate a real remedy: how a rent reduction is calculated, whether you may terminate, and how many days the landlord has to cure after notice.
  5. If the exclusivity you are asking for is unusually wide or long, have a lawyer look at the Competition Act s.90.1 risk before signing. That step can no longer be skipped.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Before you sign a retail lease, read the exclusivity clause word by word, and we will go through the documents item by item.


This article is general information only, not legal advice. The enforceability and compliance position of an exclusivity clause depend on the exact wording of your lease and the facts. Consult an Ontario lawyer before signing or enforcing.

Primary sources: Competition Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-34, s.90.1 (including the extension in force December 15, 2024, Justice Laws); Competition Bureau guidance on competitor property controls (consulted November 2026). No figures from any specific transaction are used.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation