Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

The Same Ontario Home, Two Very Different Prices: Which Number Does It Actually Sell At?

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: a home does not sell at the seller's asking price, and it does not sell at the buyer's first offer either. It sells where recent, real, completed sales can support it. When a seller and a buyer cannot agree, it is usually not because one side is being unreasonable. It is because the two sides started by measuring with different rulers.

This article covers the main line only: where the gap comes from, the three prices you need to keep separate, and what to adjust first when the gap will not close.

1. Where the gap comes from

A seller prices looking backwards. He remembers what he paid, what the renovations cost, and what a similar home on the street sold for when the market was strong. Those numbers are real, but they describe past costs and a past market — not what anyone will pay today. The longer he has lived there and the more he has put into the home, the harder that backward-looking price is to move, because lowering it feels like more than taking less money. It feels like admitting the earlier math was wrong.

A buyer offers looking at the present. He looks at what comparable homes have actually sold for in the last few months, and he works out what monthly payment he can carry and what will be left after the down payment. When the news is uncertain, his first instinct is not to stretch. It is to leave a margin, wait, and keep his conditions steady.

One side prices from the past, the other offers from the present, and the distance between those two starting points is the price expectation gap. It cannot be erased by saying "you give a little, I'll give a little," because the two sides did not even start in the same place. Admitting that is what makes the rest of the negotiation possible.

2. Keep three prices separate

Before anyone argues about price, I ask clients to write three numbers down separately and not mix them together:

Price What it is What it actually tells you
List price The price the seller asks the market to see Only the seller's opening price and strategy; it is not proof of value
Recent comparable-sales price What similar homes nearby, of the same type and in similar condition, actually sold for recently The main evidence of what today's market will pay
Offer price What the buyer will pay in this offer, read together with the closing date and conditions This buyer's specific commitment this time — not necessarily his ceiling

An example I made up, with every figure illustrative only and not a real transaction: a home is listed at $899,000 (illustrative). Recent comparable sales nearby work out to roughly $830,000 to $850,000 (illustrative). The buyer offers $820,000 (illustrative) and asks for a closing date that works for him. If the seller stares only at "almost $80,000 under asking," the talks go nowhere. If he goes back to the comparable-sales row, the real disagreement is only $10,000 to $20,000, and the rest is whether the closing date and conditions can be made to fit.

The reverse is also true. If a home is already listed close to recent sold prices, a buyer who still pushes hard simply because "buyers have choices now" has no evidence behind him either. In TRREB's monthly Market Watch, days on market are reported two ways — listing days and property days — and the property measure also counts the time before a home was relisted. When you look at how long a home has been on the market, ask which measure you are being shown, so a relisting does not make the number look smaller than the home's real time for sale.

3. When the gap will not close, adjust the data and the terms before the emotions

When price talks stall, I suggest working in this order.

First, put the evidence on the table. If a buyer offers low, list the recent sales behind that offer one by one: which street, when it sold, where the layout and condition differ, and what the price is after adjustment. If a seller holds his price, he should answer with sales too, not only with "my home is renovated." With the same set of data in front of both sides, the argument becomes whether an adjustment is reasonable — not a matter of face.

Second, negotiate price and terms together. An offer is not only a price. It also carries a closing date, a deposit, conditions such as inspection and financing, and an irrevocability period for the other side to consider it in. A seller may care that the closing lines up with his next home; a buyer may care that his financing can be confirmed inside the condition period. When those pieces fit, the remaining difference on price is often much easier to settle. Pulling one number back and forth while refusing to move on anything else is how negotiations jam.

Third, put a limit on time. A home that sits on the market is receiving feedback: few showings, and offers well below asking, both say there is distance between the asking price and today's market. A seller may wait, but he should first add up the carrying cost of waiting. A buyer may wait too, but he should decide whether he can accept it if someone else buys this home. Waiting is not a strategy. Waiting after you have done the math is.

One Ontario rule is worth stating here. Under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 and its Code of Ethics (O. Reg. 365/22), the registrant who represents you must promote and protect your best interests and must act honestly with everyone. Your confidential information — such as the lowest price you would actually accept — may not be disclosed to the other side without your written consent. So decide with your own agent, in advance, what may be said at the table and what may not. That is part of the negotiation itself.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"The list price is the market price, so a lower offer means the buyer doesn't get it." No. The list price is the seller's asking price. Market value is read from recent completed sales. An asking price with no sold support behind it does not become a market price just by sitting there longer.

"Buyers have lots of choice, so I'll throw out a low number and the seller will counter." An offer with no sales evidence behind it often gets no counter at all. The seller and his agent need a reason they can take back and discuss, and data is that reason. A low number on its own can end the negotiation at the first step.

"The price is stuck because the other agent won't help." An agent's duty is to promote and protect his own client's best interests, not to give away his client's price for the other side. When the other agent will not move, it is often because his client has not moved. Prepared evidence and workable terms do more than guessing at the other side's attitude.

If you are stuck in a price gap, do these five things in order

  1. Have your agent pull recent comparable sales first: same community, same type, actually sold in the last few months, with the differences and adjustments written out for each one. Do not price from the asking prices of homes still for sale.
  2. Write the list price, the comparable-sales price, and the price you will offer (or can accept) down as three separate numbers, and identify which segment is the real gap.
  3. When you offer or counter, send the basis with it: which sales your number was built from, so the other side has something concrete to take back and discuss.
  4. Beyond price, decide in advance which parts of the closing date, deposit and conditions you can accommodate and which you cannot, and negotiate the whole package at once instead of pulling on price alone.
  5. Set your own time and price limits in advance: how long you will wait, and at what number you will walk away or sign. Decide before, not in the few hours of an irrevocability period.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If a purchase or sale is stuck on price, bring out the recent sales first and we will go through them one by one and find exactly which segment the gap sits in.


This article is general information only, not legal advice and not a valuation of any specific property. A price judgment in a real case depends on that home's sales record, condition and contract terms. Consult an Ontario lawyer and your own agent before signing.

Primary sources: Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002, S.O. 2002, c.30 and O. Reg. 365/22 (Code of Ethics) (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026); RECO Information Guide; TRREB Market Watch notes on days-on-market measures. The $899,000, $830,000–$850,000 and $820,000 figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction.

Frequently asked questions

Is the list price the market price, so a lower offer means the buyer does not get it?

No. The list price is the seller's asking price, while market value is read from recent completed sales. An asking price with no sold support behind it does not become a market price just by sitting there longer.

Buyers have lots of choice, so will a low offer always get a counter-offer?

No. An offer with no sales evidence behind it often gets no counter at all, because the seller and his agent need a reason they can take back and discuss — and data is that reason.

If the price is stuck, is it because the other agent will not help?

No. An agent's duty is to promote and protect his own client's best interests, not to give away his client's price for the other side. When the other agent will not move, it is often because his client has not moved.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation