Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Mortgages & Finance

Open or Closed Mortgage in Canada? Start With Whether You Will Pay It Off Early

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Mortgages & Finance · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: the difference between an open and a closed mortgage is what you pay for the right to walk away. A closed mortgage carries a lower rate, but paying it off, moving it, or prepaying beyond your limit during the term usually triggers a penalty. An open mortgage can be repaid in full at any time with no prepayment penalty — and its rate is noticeably higher. So before you compare rates, answer one question: during this term, is there any real chance you will sell, move, or come into money you want to put against the whole balance?

1. What actually differs

A closed mortgage is what most borrowers hold. The bargain is simple: you commit to the contract for the term, the lender gives you a lower rate, and if you break that commitment early, a penalty returns part of the interest the lender loses. Closed does not mean you can never pay extra. Most closed contracts include prepayment privileges — a set amount you may pay each year, or a right to increase your payments — and prepaying inside that limit costs no penalty. The limit differs by lender and product; only your own contract settles it.

An open mortgage is the reverse. Nothing locks you in: you can prepay any amount, or repay the mortgage in full, at any time, with no prepayment penalty. That freedom is not free. Open rates are typically well above closed rates for a comparable term, and open products are usually short-term. Think of an open mortgage as a bridge tool, not a five-year home for a borrower who plans to stay put.

One point of confusion to clear up: open versus closed is about whether you may repay early. Fixed versus variable is about how the rate behaves. They are two separate choices and they combine — do not let the four words blur together.

2. How a closed-mortgage penalty is calculated

The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) describes the penalty this way:

  • Closed variable-rate: the penalty is usually three months' interest on the amount you prepay — your balance at your contract rate, for three months.
  • Closed fixed-rate: the penalty is usually the greater of three months' interest and the interest rate differential (IRD). The IRD is roughly the gap between your contract rate and the lender's current rate, applied to your balance over the time left in your term. The further rates have fallen and the longer your remaining term, the larger the IRD.

An illustrative example with invented numbers, only to show the arithmetic: on a $400,000 balance with three years left in a fixed term, three months' interest might come to a few thousand dollars. But if current rates sit well below the rate you signed, the IRD could come out above $10,000 — and the lender charges the higher figure. That is the real risk in a fixed closed mortgage: not that a penalty exists, but that in a falling-rate market it can be far larger than three months' interest. Before you sign, have the lender state the formula in writing, and ask the only question that matters: if I broke this contract today, what would the penalty be in dollars?

One federal protection is worth knowing: under the Interest Act, if your mortgage term is longer than five years and you have held it for more than five years, the prepayment penalty is capped at three months' interest. Most borrowers sign terms of five years or less, so it may never apply to you — but it exists.

3. The information box at the front of your contract is there for you

If your lender is a federally regulated financial institution, FCAC rules require your mortgage agreement to open with a prominent information box setting out your prepayment privileges, the penalty, and other key terms, including how the penalty is calculated. In other words, these numbers are supposed to be in front of you in plain form — you should never have to guess them.

I have seen too many borrowers read only the rate line and sign past the box. Two years later they sell or move, hear the term IRD for the first time, and face a penalty bill that stings more than the moving costs. A few tenths of a percent on the rate is a few thousand dollars over five years; a penalty you never checked can be well over $10,000 in one day. It is clear which one deserves ten minutes of your attention.

My own rule: if you expect to stay and pay normally through the term, take the closed mortgage and actually use the annual prepayment privilege — that is flexibility you do not pay extra for. If you already know you will sell soon, repay in full, or are bridging for a few months, the extra interest on an open mortgage buys you an exit with no penalty standing in the way, and that can be the cheaper deal.

Common misunderstandings

"A closed mortgage means I can never pay a dollar extra." No. Most closed contracts carry prepayment privileges, and extra payments inside the limit are penalty-free. Penalties are triggered by prepaying beyond the limit, repaying in full, or moving the mortgage to another lender mid-term.

"Open rates are higher, so an open mortgage is always a bad deal." Do not compare the rate alone. If you will sell in a few months, a closed mortgage's penalty can cost far more than the extra interest an open mortgage charges over that short stretch. Compare totals, not unit prices.

"Variable-rate means no penalty." A closed variable-rate mortgage still carries a penalty — usually three months' interest. The product with no prepayment penalty is the open mortgage; variable and penalty-free are not the same thing.

"The penalty is about three months' interest, so I roughly know it." For a fixed rate, the lender also calculates the IRD and charges the higher of the two. When rates have fallen, the IRD is often the bigger number. Signing without asking leaves a blank amount sitting in your contract.

Before you sign, do these five things in order

  1. Write down your honest plan for this term: any chance of selling, moving, refinancing, or receiving a lump sum. The plan chooses open or closed — not the other way around.
  2. With every quote, ask for more than the rate: the prepayment privilege, the penalty formula, and the dollar penalty if you broke the contract today.
  3. Read the information box at the front of the agreement, item by item, especially the prepayment and penalty sections. If anything is unclear, have the lender explain it before you sign, not after.
  4. If you choose closed, put the annual prepayment privilege in your calendar and use it — it is flexibility you are not paying extra for.
  5. If you are torn between the two, have your mortgage professional cost out both options over this one term, in dollars, and compare the totals rather than going by feel.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Before you sign a mortgage, bring the contract and the penalty terms, and we will go through the numbers item by item.


This article is general information only, not mortgage or financial advice. Prepayment privileges, penalty formulas and product terms vary by lender and product; your signed contract governs. Confirm the current figures with a licensed mortgage professional before acting.

Primary source: Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC), canada.ca pages on mortgage prepayment penalties and the mortgage information box (consulted November 2026). The $400,000 balance and other figures are illustrative only, not a real case.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation