I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: a tree standing in your own yard is not automatically yours to cut down. Many Ontario municipalities run a private tree protection bylaw. Once a tree reaches the regulated size, you need a city permit before you cut it, remove it, or even injure it. Do the work without a permit and the fine is charged per tree — and it can cost far more than the tree work itself. Buyers should pay attention too: that big backyard tree you plan to clear after closing may, in the bylaw's eyes, be a permanent part of the property you are buying.
1. Where the protection line is drawn: trunk diameter, not age, not who planted it
Take Toronto as the example. Article III of Chapter 813 of the Toronto Municipal Code — the private tree bylaw — says that a tree on private property with a trunk diameter of 30 cm or more, measured at 1.4 m above the ground, may not be cut, removed or injured without a permit. That measurement is commonly called diameter at breast height. A quick self-check: wrap a tape around the trunk at 1.4 m, take the circumference, and divide by 3.14. An illustrative example: a circumference of 110 cm works out to a diameter of about 35 cm — already over Toronto's line. A few centimetres either way flips the answer, so do not judge by eye.
Two categories of trees are easy to miss. The first is replacement trees: trees planted as a condition of an earlier removal permit are protected no matter how small they still are. The second is city trees: trees growing inside the municipal road allowance — and part of many front lawns actually sits inside that allowance — are protected at every size. Those are not "your trees" at all, and even pruning them follows city rules.
One more point: each municipality sets its own threshold. Toronto uses 30 cm; another city may use a different number, a different measuring method and different exemptions. Section 135 of Ontario's Municipal Act, 2001 is what gives municipalities the power to pass these bylaws, so there is no single province-wide answer. When you move to a new city, last city's rules do not travel with you.
2. How the permit works, and how the fine is calculated
An application goes to the city's forestry department and usually needs a report from a certified arborist setting out the species, size, condition and the reason for the work. A tree that is dead, diseased or an immediate hazard follows a comparatively direct path. A healthy tree that you want gone because of an addition, lost light or falling leaves will be reviewed much more closely, and approval often comes with conditions — planting replacement trees at a set ratio, or paying a cash-in-lieu amount for replanting.
One mistake I have seen more than once: a homeowner gets a building permit for an addition and assumes the trees inside the work area are covered. They are not. The building permit comes from the building department; the tree permit comes from forestry. They do not substitute for each other. Damaging the roots or canopy of a protected tree during construction counts as injury, and it can be pursued just like a removal.
The fine is worth stating precisely, because it changes the math: under Toronto's Chapter 813, cutting or injuring a protected tree without a permit carries a fine of $500 to $100,000 per tree. Per tree means exactly that — clear three protected trees from one lot and you are looking at three separate fines, not one package price. "Cut first and pay the fine later" rarely survives contact with those numbers.
3. Where trees surface in a purchase or sale
For buyers: if you like a house and your plan is to remove the big backyard tree and build an addition, verify that plan before you offer, not after closing. The steps are simple: measure the diameter, read the local bylaw, ask whether the tree is a replacement tree, and check whether it sits in the road allowance. If the tree cannot come down, your addition design may have to change completely — and that belongs in your offer price, not in your regrets after closing.
For sellers: a large tree in the yard is not a defect, but if a buyer asks "can this tree be removed?", the honest answer — "the bylaw has to be checked and a permit is very likely required" — is far safer than a confident promise. Also worth knowing: if the tree was planted under a permit condition by a developer or a previous owner, or if a past unpermitted removal left an outstanding replanting obligation, a buyer's lawyer may raise it during the transaction. Sorting it out early beats explaining it near closing.
My experience with these files is simple: nine times out of ten, the problem starts with "I assumed I didn't need to check." Checking costs almost nothing — a tape measure, a municipal web page, an arborist report if needed. Not checking can cost a five-figure fine plus a dead expansion plan.
Three common misunderstandings
"The tree is inside my lot lines, so it is my property and my call." Ownership and removal permission are two different things. The bylaw exists precisely to regulate trees on private land. Over the size threshold, the order is permit first, chainsaw second.
"The tree is under 30 cm, so anything goes." Not necessarily. Replacement trees are protected at any size, city trees are protected at any size, and another municipality's threshold may be lower than 30 cm. Confirm the tree's status and your city's rules before concluding anything.
"Pruning never needs a permit." Routine pruning done to good arboricultural practice generally does not. But cutting away half the canopy, or damaging the trunk and root system and calling it pruning, can amount to injury under the bylaw. When in doubt, ask the forestry department or an arborist first.
If you are about to touch a large tree in your yard, do these in order
- Measure the diameter at breast height: circumference at 1.4 m above ground, divided by 3.14. Write the number down.
- Read your own municipality's private tree bylaw for its threshold, exemptions and application process — and check whether the tree stands inside the road allowance.
- Establish whether the tree is a replacement tree planted under an earlier permit; purchase documents and prior permit records are the place to look.
- If a permit is required, have a certified arborist inspect the tree and prepare a report, then apply to the forestry department. Keep the building permit and the tree permit as two separate tracks.
- If you are buying or selling, put the tree conclusion on your due diligence list: buyers verify before offering; sellers answer honestly and promise nothing the bylaw has not confirmed.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are unsure whether a tree on your lot can be touched, measure first and check first — we will go through the bylaw and the numbers, item by item.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. Thresholds, exemptions and penalties differ by municipality, and the current text of your own city's bylaw governs. For a specific case, consult your municipal forestry department or an Ontario lawyer.
Primary sources: City of Toronto Municipal Code, Chapter 813, Article III (private tree protection) and the City of Toronto's official tree permit guidance (toronto.ca); Municipal Act, 2001, S.O. 2001, c. 25, s. 135 (Ontario e-Laws). Consulted November 2026. The 110 cm circumference figure is illustrative only.


