Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Renting, Landlords & Tenants

Your Ontario Home Is Rented Out — Your Insurance Has to Change With It: What a Landlord Policy Actually Adds

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Renting, Landlords & Tenants · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The conclusion first: once a home is rented out, the home insurance you bought as an owner-occupier is no longer enough to rely on. Rent the whole house and you will normally need a policy written for a rented dwelling. Rent only a basement or a room and you still have to tell your insurance representative in writing first, and have them confirm how the existing policy changes. What a landlord policy adds is not “more expensive coverage.” It puts three rental-only risks into the contract: your liability as a landlord, the rent you lose when tenants have to move out after an insured loss, and the things you leave in the home for tenants to use. The most dangerous mistake is also the most common one — you move out, tenants move in, and the policy quietly renews as owner-occupied without a word to the insurer.

1. A landlord policy protects the landlord, not the tenant

The Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC) draws the line plainly: a regular home policy covers property, contents and personal liability for you, your spouse and your dependants. It does not include a tenant's contents, and it does not include a tenant's personal liability.

A policy written for rental use is built around the owner's own risks. The exact wording of the policy you buy governs, but the parts to confirm are:

  • The building itself: the cost to repair or rebuild after damage from an insured loss.
  • Landlord's own contents: the fridge, stove, laundry machines and furniture you supply for tenant use. These are yours — confirm they appear in the policy instead of assuming building coverage carries them automatically.
  • Loss of rental income: IBC puts it specifically — with appropriate landlord coverage, lost rental income is replaced if tenants must vacate because of damage from an insured loss, and defence costs are covered if a legal claim is brought because a tenant or guest was injured or suffered damage on the property. Note the trigger: an insured loss. Rent arrears are not an insured loss, and neither is a unit sitting empty between tenants.
  • Landlord liability and defence costs: whether you ultimately owe anything depends on liability and the policy limits, but the defence-cost part is one of the main reasons this policy exists.

An illustrative example of my own, not a real case: you rent out a house you used to live in, an insured kitchen fire forces the tenants out for several months of repairs. The right question is not “does insurance pay?” It is four questions — where is the building repair covered, where are the appliances you supplied covered, is the lost rent for those months covered, and are defence costs covered if someone was hurt and sues? A policy is right only when all four have an answer.

2. Not telling the insurer is the most common — and most expensive — mistake

Renting changes how a home is occupied and what the risk looks like. IBC is direct: talk to your insurance representative before your living arrangement changes, and keep a written record. Failing to provide full disclosure about occupancy may void the home policy. IBC gives the example of a tenant accidentally starting a fire in a basement the insurer never knew was rented — the policy could be voided at exactly the moment it is needed most.

Ontario's Insurance Act adds a hard rule every landlord should know in outline. Section 148 deems a set of Statutory Conditions to be part of fire insurance contracts in Ontario. Condition 4 deals with a change material to the risk: a material change within your control and knowledge avoids the contract as to the part affected unless it is promptly notified in writing to the insurer or its local agent. The Act does not list which rentals count as material — that turns on the facts and the policy, and I cannot decide it for your house. But a lease you signed yourself is hard to describe as outside your knowledge or control.

Notice does not end the matter on your terms. Under Condition 4, once notified the insurer may return the unearned premium and cancel, or may require an additional premium within 15 days of your receiving its notice to keep the contract in force. Condition 5 also sets out how an insurer may terminate on notice. So the order matters: notify first, get the replacement coverage in place, and only then let the old policy end — with no gap between the two. And there is no hiding the change later: the proof of loss required after a loss under Condition 6 must state changes in use and occupation since the policy was issued. Disclosure delayed is disclosure made at the worst possible time, with no options left.

3. Tenant insurance can only be required this way — one step further does not count

Many landlords assume one line in a lease — “tenant must carry full insurance” — settles it. Section 11 of Ontario's Standard Form of Lease is narrower, and following it is what makes the requirement hold up:

  • In section 11, landlord and tenant can agree that the tenant must have liability insurance at all times, and if the landlord asks for proof of coverage, the tenant must provide it.
  • Contents insurance is the tenant's own choice. Section 11 does not let a landlord force a tenant to insure their own furniture and electronics. Liability is the part you can require.
  • No Ontario law makes tenant insurance automatic for every tenant. The obligation comes from the option selected in the signed lease, so select it and write it clearly at signing — not after move-in.

My practice is to keep the two policies separate in your mind: buy your own landlord coverage correctly first, then use section 11 for tenant liability insurance, collect proof before move-in, and ask for it again each year — IBC's tips for landlords include requiring proof of insurance annually. The two policies cover different people and different property, and together they close the most common gap: a tenant whose belongings are destroyed turning to the landlord, whose policy never covered tenant belongings in the first place.

Common misunderstandings

Misunderstanding 1: “I still live upstairs and only rent the basement, so it isn't really renting.” Whether it counts is not decided by what you call it. IBC lists renting out a basement or a bedroom and taking in boarders as changes to discuss with your insurance representative first. A partial rental gets written notice too.

Misunderstanding 2: “Landlord insurance will cover rent arrears and deliberate damage by tenants.” Do not assume that. The rental-income protection IBC describes is triggered by an insured loss forcing tenants out. Arrears are a lease and enforcement problem, not a fire or water loss. Where tenant-caused damage sits in your policy, and what is excluded, has to be asked item by item and read in the wording — not guessed from common sense.

Misunderstanding 3: “A few empty weeks don't matter; the policy is still in force.” Vacancy changes the risk, and many policies set their own conditions and time limits for it. The gap between tenants, or the weeks after you move out before a sale closes, should be raised in advance — not discovered in the wording after a loss.

Misunderstanding 4: “I mentioned the rental to my broker on the phone, so I'm covered.” Statutory Condition 4 calls for notice in writing. A phone call with no record is hard to prove in a dispute. One factual email, kept with the reply, is the cheapest protection in this whole topic.

Before a tenant moves in, I suggest doing it in this order

  1. Before the living arrangement changes, notify your insurance representative in writing: whole home or part of it, the start date, and whether you still live there. Keep the notice and the reply.
  2. If you do not live in the property, plan on a separate rented-dwelling policy, as IBC describes. Do not cancel the old policy first — line the new policy's start date up so there is no gap.
  3. Ask, item by item, and write down the answers: the building; the appliances and furniture you supply; lost rental income; landlord liability and defence costs — which part of the policy each sits in, its limit and its exclusions. Ask separately about vacancy periods and add-ons such as sewer back-up and overland water.
  4. In section 11 of the standard lease, select the option requiring the tenant to carry liability insurance, and collect proof of coverage before move-in. Leave contents insurance as the tenant's choice; do not write it in as compulsory.
  5. Every year during the tenancy, do two things: ask the tenant for current proof of insurance again, and at renewal check that the use and occupancy described in your policy still match how the home is actually lived in.
  6. If the number of tenants, the rented area, or your own living arrangement changes again, notify in writing again. Do not rely on what was said last time.

I am Ming Ren. Before you hand over the keys, get the policy lined up with the way the home is actually used — clause by clause, not by assumption.


This article is general information only, not insurance advice and not legal advice. The wording, exclusions and limits of the policy you buy decide what is covered. Confirm your own property with a licensed insurance broker or agent, and consult an Ontario lawyer where needed. Property and casualty insurance in Ontario is regulated by the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA).

Primary sources: Insurance Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. I.8, ss.143, 148 (Statutory Conditions 1, 4, 5, 6), Ontario e-Laws; Insurance Bureau of Canada, “Renting out a room? What you need to know about insurance”; Ontario Standard Form of Lease, s.11, and the Government of Ontario's Guide to Ontario's standard lease; FSRA Ontario consumer guidance on property and other insurance (checked November 2026). The kitchen-fire example above is illustrative and is not a real case; this article gives no premium or payout figures.

Frequently asked questions

I still live upstairs and only rent the basement, so it isn't really renting?

Whether it counts is not decided by what you call it. IBC lists renting out a basement or a bedroom and taking in boarders as changes to discuss with your insurance representative first. A partial rental gets written notice too.

Will landlord insurance cover rent arrears and deliberate damage by tenants?

Do not assume that. The rental-income protection IBC describes is triggered by an insured loss forcing tenants out. Arrears are a lease and enforcement problem, not a fire or water loss; where tenant-caused damage sits in your policy has to be asked item by item and read in the wording.

A few empty weeks don't matter; the policy is still in force?

Vacancy changes the risk, and many policies set their own conditions and time limits for it. The gap between tenants, or the weeks after you move out before a sale closes, should be raised in advance — not discovered in the wording after a loss.

I mentioned the rental to my broker on the phone, so I'm covered?

Statutory Condition 4 calls for notice in writing. A phone call with no record is hard to prove in a dispute. One factual email, kept with the reply, is the cheapest protection in this whole topic.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation