I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The conclusion first: an Ontario estate trustee is entitled to be paid, but the statute gives no price list. Section 61 of the Trustee Act says only this: a trustee is entitled to such fair and reasonable allowance for their care, pains and trouble, and time expended in and about the estate, as may be allowed by a judge. The "5%" people quote is a court-developed guideline — 2.5% on receipts plus 2.5% on disbursements — and it is only a starting point. The result is then checked against five factors, and if the will itself fixes compensation, the will governs instead. Understand this before the estate house is sold, and the family conversation afterwards is far easier.
1. Where 2.5% plus 2.5% comes from
The court convention, often called the tariff guideline, applies 2.5% to each of four accounts: capital receipts, capital disbursements, revenue receipts and revenue disbursements. Because an asset normally comes in once and goes out once — the house sells and the proceeds come in; the money is later paid out to beneficiaries — charging 2.5% on both sides produces a total near 5% of the estate's gross value. Where an estate must be administered over years rather than distributed at once, an additional care and management fee may apply: two-fifths of 1% (0.4%) per year on the average annual value of assets under administration.
The house sale makes this concrete: sale proceeds are a capital receipt, counted once at 2.5%; when that money is later distributed, it is counted again as a disbursement at 2.5%. The sale contributes on both legs, not as a single commission at closing.
And the guideline is not an entitlement. The approach confirmed by the Court of Appeal, including in Re Laing Estate, is two-step: calculate the tariff figure, then test it for overall fairness against five factors, adjusting up or down as the case requires. A very large but simple estate, or a very small but troublesome one, can both end up far from the guideline number.
2. The five factors, and why the will comes first
The five factors are: the size of the estate; the care and responsibility involved; the time occupied in performing the duties; the skill and ability shown; and the success resulting from the administration. Applied to selling an estate home, they are concrete questions: was the house sold in a timely way, at a reasonable price, without extra costs caused by the trustee's delay? Strong answers support the guideline; weak ones reduce it. A genuinely difficult administration — disputes, a complicated property, heavy documented time — can support the guideline or more.
Two priority rules. First, the will: under subsection 61(5) of the Trustee Act, where the instrument itself fixes the trustee's compensation, section 61's discretionary scheme does not apply — the document governs. So the first step is always to read the will for a compensation clause. Second, approval: compensation agreed to by all beneficiaries can generally be implemented on that basis, but where there is disagreement, or beneficiaries under disability such as minors, the amount is set through the court process of passing of accounts. A trustee who simply picks a number and pays it to themselves is lighting the most common fuse in estate disputes.
3. Timing against the house sale, and the tax point
Compensation is normally settled near the end of the administration, when the accounts are complete — not skimmed off when the house sells. The reason is arithmetic: the base is the estate's total receipts and disbursements, which is unknowable until the accounts are done. Taking too much early means repaying on a later passing of accounts. Sale proceeds, once in the estate account, serve the estate first — debts, taxes, costs — with compensation calculated at the accounting stage.
Tax is not optional detail. Trustee compensation is taxable income to the person receiving it. For a non-professional trustee, such as a family member, CRA generally treats the fee as income from an office or employment: the estate issues a T4 and withholds accordingly, and the recipient reports it. "It is just a thank-you payment within the family" is not a tax position.
An illustrative calculation only, showing the guideline arithmetic — not a real case, and not a prediction of what any court would approve: an estate of $1,000,000, fully collected and fully paid out, gives receipts of $1,000,000 × 2.5% = $25,000, plus disbursements of $1,000,000 × 2.5% = $25,000, totalling $50,000, roughly 5%. That figure must still pass the five-factor test; a simple, undisputed, quickly administered estate can properly end below it. Quoting the guideline to family as a guaranteed wage is the fastest way to damage the relationship the work was meant to serve.
Three common misunderstandings
"The law gives the executor 5%; it is a statutory commission." No. Section 61 of the Trustee Act provides a fair and reasonable allowance as allowed by a judge. The 2.5% plus 2.5% is a court guideline, still subject to the five-factor check.
"The will says nothing about pay, so the trustee works for free." No. Where the will is silent, section 61's mechanism exists precisely for that case. Where the will does fix compensation, the will governs and the guideline is not applied on top.
"It is family money — no tax, no accounting needed." Both are needed. Compensation is taxable income with T4 reporting; and where amounts are disputed or beneficiaries include minors, the court's passing of accounts is the route, not self-assessment.
If you are the estate trustee selling the house, do these in order
- Read the will first for a compensation clause. If there is one, it governs; if not, work within section 61's guideline-and-factors approach.
- Keep records from day one: time spent, tasks handled, key decisions on the house sale and their price basis — the five factors are assessed on exactly this evidence.
- Let sale proceeds serve the estate first: debts, taxes and costs before any thought of compensation, and do not take compensation early.
- When the accounts are complete, walk adult beneficiaries through the calculation and its basis; where everyone agrees, record the agreement in writing.
- Where a beneficiary is a minor, someone objects, or the amount is uncertain, use the passing of accounts process — and confirm the tax treatment (T4 and withholding) in advance.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Money between family members goes best when the calculation and the records are on the table. That is how the fee never costs a relationship.
This article is general information only, not legal or tax advice. Compensation in a specific estate depends on the will, beneficiary consent, or a court order. Consult an Ontario estate lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Trustee Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. T.23, s.61 (Ontario e-Laws); the tariff guideline and five-factor approach confirmed in Re Laing Estate (Ont. C.A.) (consulted November 2026). The $1,000,000 and $50,000 figures are illustrative only, not a real case.
Frequently asked questions
Does the law give the executor 5 percent as a statutory commission?
No. Section 61 of the Trustee Act provides a fair and reasonable allowance as allowed by a judge. The 2.5 percent plus 2.5 percent is a court guideline, still subject to the five-factor check.
If the will says nothing about pay, does the trustee work for free?
No. Where the will is silent, section 61's mechanism exists precisely for that case. Where the will does fix compensation, the will governs and the guideline is not applied on top.
Is trustee compensation just family money, with no tax or accounting needed?
Both are needed. Compensation is taxable income with T4 reporting, and where amounts are disputed or beneficiaries include minors, the court's passing of accounts is the route, not self-assessment.


