I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: the most common downsizing mistake is not overpaying for the smaller home. It is comparing only the two prices and ignoring the costs, tax and sequencing in between. A price gap that looks like six figures can shrink by half — or disappear — once the move is fully costed. Work through the three items below before you decide.
1. The smaller home still attracts land transfer tax — and there is no first-time buyer refund
Any purchase that transfers title in Ontario attracts provincial land transfer tax on the price. The Ontario Ministry of Finance rates are graduated:
| Portion of price | Rate |
|---|---|
| First $55,000 | 0.5% |
| $55,000–$250,000 | 1.0% |
| $250,000–$400,000 | 1.5% |
| $400,000–$2,000,000 | 2.0% |
| Above $2,000,000 (one or two single-family residences) | 2.5% |
An illustrative example I made up, only to show the arithmetic: on a $700,000 purchase, the provincial tax is about $10,475 (275 + 1,950 + 2,250 + 6,000). If the new home is inside Toronto, the Toronto municipal land transfer tax applies on top, at a broadly similar scale, so the tax bill roughly doubles.
One more point many people miss: the first-time homebuyer refund, up to $4,000, requires that you have never owned a home anywhere in the world. Downsizers have owned a home, so do not put that refund in your budget — budget the tax in full.
Then add the rest of the one-time costs: commission on the sale, legal fees on both transactions, moving, disposing of belongings, and any work on the new home. Only the number left after all of those lines is the real result of the move.
2. Sell first or buy first: decide from cash flow, not habit
Neither order is right for everyone:
| Sell first | Buy first | |
|---|---|---|
| Budget | Sale proceeds in hand; the number is certain | You fund two homes briefly; bridge financing may be needed |
| Housing gap | You may need a short rental or temporary stay | You move on your own schedule |
| Main risk | Nothing suitable to buy right away | The old home sells slowly and carrying costs stack up |
My rule is simple: if cash flow is tight and you cannot carry two homes, sell first. If you are comfortable financially and the right home will not wait, buying first can work — but confirm the bridge arrangement with your mortgage broker before you sign, not after.
One tax note: a principal residence you lived in can generally be sheltered by the principal residence exemption, but a family unit can designate only one property per year, and since 2016 the sale must still be reported on Schedule 3 with a designation on Form T2091(IND), even when the gain is fully exempt. Late designations can attract penalties. Ask your accountant before you choose which property to sell first.
3. Count rooms and belongings by real use, not by default
Clearing a home lived in for decades is the step that most often stalls the whole plan. Start months ahead and work in batches rather than leaving it to the final week. The other default worth questioning is the spare room kept for children and grandchildren. Count honestly how many nights a year it is actually used: a rarely used extra room costs more purchase price, more property tax and more upkeep, every year. Keep it if the numbers still make sense to you — but make it a decision, not a default.
If the new home will sit empty for long stretches, for example while you spend half the year abroad, check your policy's vacancy definition and day limits first, and arrange for someone to check the home regularly. Water damage usually happens when nobody is there.
Common misunderstandings
“The price difference is the money I save.” No. Commission, legal fees, land transfer tax, moving and repairs all come out of that difference first.
“A smaller home means little tax, and I may still get a refund.” The tax is calculated on the new home's price in graduated brackets, whatever its size, and prior homeowners do not qualify for the first-time buyer refund.
“I will give the sale proceeds to my children first and plan around what is left.” That is the wrong order. Fund your own living, medical and care costs for the years ahead first; only what is genuinely surplus should be considered for the children. Money given away is hard to take back.
My checklist before you commit
- Build one table of every one-time cost on both transactions, with real quotes, including land transfer tax at your target price — and the Toronto municipal tax if the home is in Toronto.
- Confirm you do not qualify for the first-time buyer refund, and leave the $4,000 out of the budget.
- Decide sell-first or buy-first from your cash flow; if buying first, arrange bridge financing before making an offer.
- If you own more than one property, talk to your accountant about principal residence designation and reporting (Schedule 3 and Form T2091(IND)) before choosing what sells first.
- Start clearing belongings months ahead, in batches, and choose the new home's room count by actual use.
- If the new home will be vacant for long periods, confirm the vacancy terms with your insurance broker and line up regular checks.
I am Ming Ren. Fill in the cost table first, and we will go through the numbers line by line before anyone signs anything.
This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. Rates and refund eligibility are as published by the Ontario Ministry of Finance; consult an Ontario lawyer and an accountant about your own case.
Primary sources: Ontario Ministry of Finance, Land Transfer Tax and First-Time Homebuyers Refund (ontario.ca, consulted November 2026); Canada Revenue Agency, Principal Residence and Other Real Estate (canada.ca). The $700,000 and $10,475 figures are illustrative, not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
Is the price difference between the big home and the smaller one the money I save?
No. Commission, legal fees, land transfer tax, moving and repairs all come out of that difference first, and only what remains is savings.
Does a smaller home mean little land transfer tax, and can I still get the first-time buyer refund?
The tax is calculated on the new home's price in graduated brackets whatever its size, and prior homeowners do not qualify for the first-time buyer refund.
Should I give the sale proceeds to my children first and plan around what is left?
That is the wrong order. Fund your own living, medical and care costs for the years ahead first, and only consider genuinely surplus money for the children, because money given away is hard to take back.


