Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Condos

Detached House or Condo in the GTA: Who Really Appreciated More Over 10 Years?

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Condos · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: over many past decades, GTA detached houses have generally appreciated more than condos, and that broad direction is right. But if you act on a single percentage, you will probably do the math wrong. The two are not the same kind of asset: with a detached house you are mostly buying land; with a condo you are mostly buying a unit inside a building. Before comparing appreciation, use the same yardstick for both, subtract the cost of holding each one, and then run the numbers for your own budget and holding period. Get those three calculations right and the answer takes care of itself.

Plenty of 10-year comparison figures circulate online, each measured differently — some use average prices, some use a handful of sales. I am not recycling any of those percentages here. What follows is the method. Learn it, and you can run the comparison yourself.

Calculation 1: Use the same yardstick, or the comparison is wrong from the start

The most common mistake is treating the average selling price as appreciation. An average price is total sales dollars divided by the number of sales, and it moves with the mix of what sold: sell more large houses this month and the average rises, even if no individual home gained a dollar in value.

A sourced example. TRREB's Market Watch for October 2026 (released November 4, 2026) shows the GTA average selling price for all home types down 2.7% year-over-year, while the MLS® HPI Composite benchmark price was down 4.3% over the same period. Same market, same month, two different numbers — because they measure differently. The HPI benchmark tracks the price of a constant "typical" home of each type, stripping out changes in sales mix; the average does not.

So if you want a fair 10-year comparison, do this:

  • One yardstick for both sides: MLS® HPI benchmark prices for both, or median sold prices for the same area and home type for both — never an average on one side and individual cases on the other.
  • The same stretch of road: The same community and the same start and end dates. Comparing a core-area detached house with a suburban high-rise condo compares locations, not home types.
  • Watch the starting base: A detached house starts at a much higher total price, so the same 30% gain is a very different dollar amount; a condo starts lower, and a prettier percentage may still be fewer dollars. Read the percentage and the dollars together.

From that same October 2026 report: the GTA average selling price that month was $1,310,627 for detached houses and $621,400 for condo apartments. The starting points differ by more than two to one — which is exactly why a percentage alone misleads.

Calculation 2: Where the gap comes from — land, supply, and fees

With the yardstick fixed, the gap comes mainly from three things.

First, how much of the price is land. A large share of a detached house's value is its lot. Land does not depreciate, and the supply of lots that can hold a detached house in a built-up city barely grows. A condo unit carries only a small share of land; most of its value is the building itself, and buildings age. Elevators, garages and exterior walls eventually need major money. Over a 10-year span, the asset with the higher land share usually has the structural advantage — not because anyone forecast well, but because of what the asset is made of.

Second, whether supply can respond. New detached supply arrives slowly; a street adds only a few houses over years. Condos are different: one site can deliver hundreds of units at once, and when completions cluster in a few years, resale units in that area compete against each other on price. When buying a condo, "how many new projects complete nearby in the next three years" is a question you must ask.

Third, maintenance fees eating the return. A detached house's holding costs are scattered — property tax, insurance, utilities, plus a roof or furnace every so often — and you control the timing. A condo's monthly fee is fixed, comes out every month, and usually rises year by year. Over ten years it is real money: it reduces cash flow while you hold, and buyers discount for a high fee when you sell. A 10-year condo return calculated without the fees has not actually been calculated.

Calculation 3: Run your own net return

Here is the method; fill in your own numbers:

Net return = sale price − purchase price − all holding costs over the period − transaction costs on both ends

For a detached house, holding costs mean tax, insurance and a maintenance reserve. For a condo, they mean tax, insurance and the total of the monthly fees. Transaction costs on both sides include land transfer tax, legal fees and selling commission.

A worked example I made up — every figure is a hypothetical, shown only to demonstrate the arithmetic: suppose a condo bought for $600,000 sells ten years later for $720,000, a paper gain of $120,000. If fees averaged a hypothetical $550 a month, that is $66,000 over ten years, before transaction costs — and the net return thins out quickly. Take a detached house bought for a hypothetical $1,200,000 and sold for $1,500,000: a $300,000 paper gain, against a hypothetical $80,000 of repairs and major items over the decade, leaves a very different net figure. The point is not which hypothetical wins. The point is that a gain quoted before costs is always larger than the money you actually keep.

Two more variables not to miss. Holding period: if you will move within three to five years, short-term swings and transaction costs matter more than any 10-year pattern; the long-run comparison will not save you. Total price versus price per square foot: condos often cost more per square foot, but you own the total asset, and appreciation is earned on the total dollars, not on the per-foot figure.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"Detached appreciated more, so I should stretch into a detached house." An appreciation figure is a market-wide average across a home type. You are buying one specific property. A stretched purchase of a far-suburban detached house does not automatically beat a good condo in a core location — the location calculation is bigger than the home-type calculation.

"Condo fees are wasted money; a detached house doesn't have that cost." A detached house has it under different names: roof, exterior walls, driveway, furnace — all paid by you, sooner or later. The difference is that condo costs arrive monthly and visibly, while detached costs land in large lumps years apart and are easy to forget to reserve for.

"It rose by X over ten years, so that is what I would make." A headline gain deducts neither holding costs nor transaction costs, and ignores what your down payment and payments could have done elsewhere. Finish Calculation 3 above; what remains is the number worth comparing.

If you are choosing between the two, do these things in order

  1. Fix your holding period first. If you expect to hold for under five years, do not borrow a 10-year conclusion — work out transaction costs and short-term risk instead.
  2. Pull the data with one yardstick: in TRREB's Market Watch, find the MLS® HPI benchmark change for your target community and home type, with the same start and end dates on both sides.
  3. Run the net return for each candidate property: purchase price, estimated sale price, ten years of holding costs, and transaction costs on both ends — one sheet per property.
  4. Condos need one extra step: check the fee history over recent years, the reserve fund's health, and new supply completing in the next three years. Detached houses need a different extra step: list the big-ticket years — roof, furnace, exterior work — based on the home's age.
  5. Ask the home-type question last. If two options in the same budget and community come out close on net return, choose the one you will live in comfortably and can actually maintain — for an owner-occupied home, the living is part of the return.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are torn between a detached house and a condo, give me your budget, the areas you are considering and how long you plan to hold, and we will work through the calculations above, line by line.


This article is general information only, not investment or financial advice. Prices, taxes and fees vary by property and period. Before deciding, consider your own financial situation and consult a qualified professional where appropriate.

Primary source: TRREB Market Watch, October 2026 (released November 4, 2026; consulted November 2026): GTA average selling price of $1,310,627 for detached houses and $621,400 for condo apartments that month; all-types average price −2.7% year-over-year; MLS® HPI Composite benchmark −4.3% year-over-year. The $600,000, $720,000, $1,200,000, $1,500,000 figures, the $550 monthly fee and the $80,000 repair figure are illustrative hypotheticals only, not real transactions or statistics.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation