Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Commercial Real Estate & Leasing

What Does the City Charge for Those Extra Storeys? Ontario's Community Benefits Charge, Explained

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Commercial Real Estate & Leasing · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The conclusion first: developers used to negotiate extra height and density with the city, project by project. That bargaining regime has largely been retired and replaced by a formula with a statutory ceiling — the community benefits charge (CBC), imposed under section 37 of Ontario's Planning Act. The cap is 4% of land value, and the charge does not apply to every project. Before a development pro forma means anything, three things have to be settled: the trigger, the denominator, and the valuation day.

1. First, does your project even trigger the charge?

The CBC is not universal. Under the s.37 framework and O. Reg. 509/20, it is aimed at higher-density development, and two conditions must be met at the same time:

Trigger Requirement
Height A building of five or more storeys
Residential units Adds or contains ten or more residential units

Five storeys with eight units does not trigger it. Twelve units in four storeys does not trigger it. The test is "and," not "or." Two further conditions matter: the municipality must actually have passed its own CBC by-law, supported by a CBC strategy — the tool is available to municipalities, not mandatory — and the regulation exempts certain categories of development, which have to be checked project by project. A mixed-use building can be caught if its residential component meets the thresholds.

Some history worth knowing: the old s.37 was density bonusing — cash or in-kind community benefits negotiated in exchange for extra height and density, with a price nobody could predict in advance. Bill 108 and the reforms that followed replaced that mechanism with the CBC, and the transition period ended on September 18, 2022. Most of the "how to negotiate section 37" advice still circulating online describes the old world. Do not build a new pro forma on it.

2. Four per cent is a ceiling, and the denominator is the land

This is where pro formas go wrong. Section 37(32) and section 3 of O. Reg. 509/20 cap the charge at 4% of the value of the land. Three points follow:

  • 4% is the maximum, not the rate. A municipality may set a lower rate in its by-law; it may not exceed the cap. The actual rate is whatever the project's municipality has enacted — check the current by-law rather than assuming the ceiling applies everywhere.
  • The denominator is the land alone — not the completed project's value, not gross sales, not construction cost. Applying 4% to total project value produces a wildly overstated number and is the most common beginner's error in a development budget.
  • What the money funds is the capital cost of facilities and services made necessary by growth. The CBC does not replace development charges, and it does not replace parkland contributions; the three rest on different legal bases and run in parallel, so a cost sheet should carry them on three separate lines.

A purely illustrative example, with invented numbers to show the arithmetic only: if the land value on the valuation day is $10,000,000 and the municipality charges at the cap, the CBC is $400,000 — 4% of the land, not 4% of whatever the finished project eventually sells for. If the by-law rate is below the cap, use the by-law rate.

3. The valuation day is the day before the first building permit

Under the s.37 framework, land value is assessed as of the day before the first building permit for the development is issued. That timing has two consequences a developer should price in from the start.

First, the valuation happens after planning approvals are in hand. The land being valued carries its approved development rights, so its value will usually reflect the approvals themselves, not the price originally paid for the site. The uplift created by the approval process is inside the denominator.

Second, this is early-stage cash. The charge falls due around permit issuance — before construction, and long before any sales or rental revenue arrives. In a cash-flow model it is not enough to record the amount; the timing of the outflow, at the most capital-hungry point of the project, is part of the cost.

If you dispute the amount, the later subsections of s.37 (in the range of subsections 33 to 43) set out a valuation-dispute process, including owner-commissioned appraisals and a comparison of values. In practice the sequence is to keep the permit process moving, preserve your objection rights, and fight over the denominator through that process rather than stalling at the counter. Have a planning lawyer walk the steps against your municipality's by-law, because municipal detail is not uniform.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"The CBC is just the new name for development charges." It is not. Development charges rest on their own statute, the Development Charges Act, 1997, with their own methodology; the CBC is a separate Planning Act s.37 charge; parkland is a third contribution again. The three run in parallel and none offsets another.

"Four per cent is charged on the value of the whole project." No. The base is the value of the land on the valuation day. Substituting total project value overstates the cost so badly that viable projects get wrongly killed on paper.

"I am charged because I asked for extra density." That was the logic of the old regime, where the payment was the price of a negotiated increase. Under the CBC, the trigger is simply the two thresholds — storeys and units. Build five storeys and ten units entirely within your existing permissions and the charge can still apply.

When you run the numbers on a development, do these five things in order

  1. Test the trigger first: are both thresholds — five or more storeys, ten or more residential units — met? Then confirm the municipality has a CBC by-law in force and find its current rate.
  2. Have the land appraised as of the day before the first building permit would issue, multiply by the by-law rate, and note the statutory ceiling of 4% beside the figure.
  3. Carry the CBC, development charges and parkland on three separate lines of the cost sheet, each with its own legal basis. Never bury them in one "government charges" total.
  4. Place the CBC at the permit stage of the cash-flow model and arrange funding for it there, rather than discovering the payment when the permit application is filed.
  5. If you intend to challenge the land value, ask a planning lawyer about the s.37 valuation-dispute process and its deadlines before signing anything that confirms the amount — preserve the right first, dispute second.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. On a development deal, separate the three charges, get the denominator right, and only then decide whether the project works.


This article is general information only, not legal advice. CBC by-laws, rates and exemptions differ by municipality. Confirm the current by-law for the municipality where the project sits, and consult an Ontario planning lawyer on individual cases.

Primary sources: Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, s.37 (including the s.37(32) cap and the valuation-dispute process in ss.37(33)–(43)) (Ontario e-Laws); O. Reg. 509/20, s.3 (consulted November 2026). The $10,000,000 and $400,000 figures are illustrative only, not a real project.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation