I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: on a newly built or recently renovated commercial property, the tax bill on your closing date is often not the property's real tax bill. Frequently only the land has been assessed so far, and the building is not on the roll yet. When MPAC (the Municipal Property Assessment Corporation) later adds the assessment, the municipality issues a retroactive bill. That bill can cover days after you took title — and a period while the seller still owned the property. Without a holdback and an apportionment clause agreed in advance, the person holding the property usually ends up carrying the whole amount first.
1. Where the later bill comes from: assessment happens in two passes
Ontario property tax rests on MPAC's assessment. After new construction, an addition or a major renovation, assessment takes time to catch up with reality. Land first, building later is a common sequence.
The Assessment Act provides two routes that produce these later bills:
| Type | Section | In outline |
|---|---|---|
| Supplementary assessment | s.34 | Where a change such as new construction or an addition occurs during the year, the assessment is added and tax is levied on it |
| Omitted assessment | s.33 | Assessment that was previously omitted is added back, potentially reaching the current year and earlier years, as the section and the facts allow |
The critical feature is retroactivity. The added tax is not charged only from the day the bill is mailed. It covers the period during which the property should have been assessed. If that period straddles your closing date, the seller's portion should not, in fairness, be yours — but the municipality's bill is addressed to the property and its current owner. It will not chase your seller for you. Recovering the seller's share depends on your contract, not on the tax bill.
2. Why the closing tax adjustment does not solve this
At closing, your lawyer adjusts taxes by apportioning the bills that have already been issued, day by day: the seller bears the days before closing, you bear the days after. That step is correct — but it can only divide bills that exist.
A supplementary or omitted bill is different in kind: it is a new bill, created after closing, for a past period. Once the closing documents are signed and the money has moved, the seller has no obligation to return and pay their portion — unless the agreement said so in advance: how a later supplementary or omitted bill is to be apportioned, what cooperation the seller must give, and what money stands behind that promise. That is the entire point of a holdback: part of the seller's closing proceeds stays back until the supplementary-bill risk has been settled or the agreed period has run.
How much to hold, and for how long, has no single province-wide answer. It depends on how new the property is, how likely a catch-up assessment is, and the estimated tax exposure. An invented example: on a newly completed commercial building priced at $3 million, a lawyer estimates potential supplementary exposure of roughly $40,000, and the parties agree to hold back a comparable amount, releasable when the supplementary position is settled or the agreed period expires. Every figure here is illustrative; the amount and the period must be set by your lawyer on the facts of your deal.
3. Four things the contract should actually say
In my experience, at least these four points belong in the agreement or the closing documents, not in a verbal understanding:
First, an apportionment rule for later bills: any supplementary or omitted tax bill issued after closing is shared by days of ownership, with the seller bearing the period before closing.
Second, the holdback mechanics: the amount, whose trust account holds it, what documents trigger release, and what happens when the agreed period expires.
Third, notice and cooperation: whichever side receives a supplementary bill or an MPAC assessment notice passes it to the other promptly, and the seller provides tax bills and payment records from their period of ownership.
Fourth, the separate assessment-appeal track: if you believe the supplementary assessment value itself is wrong, assessment appeals run on their own deadlines and procedures. That is a different line from recovering the seller's share — do not let one wait for the other.
Risk also varies by property. A long-established property with a settled assessment carries relatively low supplementary risk. The highest risk sits with property that has just been completed, added to, or changed in use. The newer your property is, the less optional this clause becomes.
Common misunderstandings
"Taxes were adjusted at closing, so a later bill has nothing to do with the seller." The closing adjustment only divided bills already issued. A later bill retroactive to the seller's period can only be recovered from the seller through an apportionment and holdback clause agreed in advance.
"The city billed the wrong person — I will just argue with the city." Most supplementary bills are not errors. They are the normal levy that follows a catch-up assessment. Challenging the assessed value is an MPAC and appeal question; it does not decide how buyer and seller share the bill between themselves.
"A holdback means we do not trust the seller." It does not. A holdback is the standard commercial tool for a future bill whose amount is not yet known. It protects both sides: the seller also gains a clean, contract-based settlement instead of open-ended claims years later.
"A year has passed with no bill, so none is coming." Omitted assessments can reach into earlier years, on a longer timeline than many buyers assume. Set the holdback period against that risk, not against a feeling that a quiet year means safety.
If you are buying new or recently renovated commercial property, do these in order
- Ask about assessment status in due diligence: confirm with your lawyer and the seller whether MPAC has assessed land only, or land plus building, and whether any construction, addition or change of use is not yet reflected.
- Have your lawyer estimate the potential supplementary exposure, and propose the holdback amount and period on that basis — inside the agreement, not the day before closing.
- Write the apportionment rule, the notice duty and the release conditions into the agreement or closing documents, clause by clause, signed by both sides.
- After closing, watch for MPAC assessment notices and municipal tax bills. When a supplementary bill arrives, calculate each side's days of ownership first, then apply the contract.
- If you dispute the assessed value itself, have your lawyer confirm the appeal deadline immediately and run both tracks — internal apportionment and external appeal — at the same time.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. When you buy a new building, arrange for the tax bill that has not arrived yet — then close.
This article is general information only, not legal or tax advice. The years reachable by an omitted or supplementary assessment, and any apportionment, depend on the statute's application and the contract wording. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Assessment Act, R.S.O. 1990, c.A.31, s.33 (omitted assessment) and s.34 (supplementary assessment); Municipal Act, 2001 tax provisions; MPAC's published explanation of supplementary and omitted assessments (consulted November 2026). The $3 million and $40,000 figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction.


