I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: if a buyer breaches, the deposit is most likely lost — that is what a deposit is for. But "lost" does not mean "automatically transferred to the seller." In Ontario the deposit sits locked in a trust account, and the brokerage has no authority to decide who gets it. The money moves by only three routes: a mutual release signed by both parties, a court order, or a normal closing. Understand those three routes and the rules behind them, and you are ahead of most people arguing about refunds.
First: from the moment it is paid, the deposit is nobody's to hand out
Under the standard wording of OREA Form 100, where "Upon Acceptance" is selected, the buyer must deliver the deposit to the named Deposit Holder within 24 hours of acceptance, by negotiable cheque, to be held in trust pending completion or other termination of the agreement, and credited toward the purchase price on completion. "Herewith" means it accompanies the offer itself.
Where the deposit holder is a brokerage, TRESA and its regulations require the money to go into the brokerage's Real Estate Trust Account — the regulation requires deposit into the trust account within five business days of receipt — and it may be paid out only in accordance with the terms of the trust. That means the seller cannot phone the brokerage and ask for the deposit early, and the buyer cannot change their mind and demand it back. The brokerage has no discretion in the matter; it is a custodian, not a judge.
One more point: the 24 hours is a hard deadline. It includes weekends and holidays, and it runs from the acceptance time recorded in the Confirmation of Acceptance. A late deposit is itself a breach — "one day late" is not a defence.
Second: after a breach, the deposit follows process, not emotion
On a normal closing, the deposit flows through the lawyers and is credited to the down payment; nobody argues. The trouble exists only when one side breaches and the other does not accept it.
The most common resolution is a negotiated Mutual Release: the parties agree in writing that the deal is terminated and how the deposit is dealt with — all to the seller, all back to the buyer, or split. The brokerage releases the funds on that signed document. This is why many disputes end in a split: litigation time and cost are real, and each side giving a little is often the rational outcome.
If there is no agreement, the only route is court — Small Claims Court within its monetary jurisdiction, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice above it. The brokerage then releases strictly as the court order directs. With neither a mutual release nor an order, the deposit simply stays in trust, for months or even years. That is not the brokerage stalling; the rules forbid it to move the money.
Third: buyer breach usually means forfeiture — with two important limits
The principle first. At Ontario common law, a buyer who refuses to close without legal justification generally forfeits the deposit, and the seller does not first have to prove the amount of actual loss — securing performance is the deposit's function, and the Court of Appeal has confirmed this in a line of cases. Forfeiture is also not the seller's whole remedy: if the seller resells for less and incurs extra costs, the shortfall can be claimed as well, with the deposit credited against the total damages awarded.
The first limit is the court's equitable power. Section 98 of the Courts of Justice Act lets a court grant relief against penalties and forfeitures on just terms. The Court of Appeal's test has two steps: whether the forfeited sum is out of all proportion to the seller's actual damages, and whether it would be unconscionable for the seller to retain it. Both must be satisfied, and the bar is high. A market drop or a failed financing, on its own, does not clear it. Relief is the exception, not an exit strategy.
The second limit runs the other way: if the seller is the one who breaches, or the deal dies because of the seller, the buyer is entitled to the full deposit back and may claim their own losses on top. The deposit was never "the seller's money no matter what." It secures the buyer's performance — and that logic reverses when the seller defaults.
An illustrative example I made up: a buyer pays a $50,000 deposit, then backs out. The seller resells two months later for $30,000 less. The seller's real loss is roughly $30,000 plus extra costs, and the $50,000 deposit roughly covers it with some surplus. If the buyer seeks relief under s. 98, they must persuade a court that keeping the whole amount is out of proportion and unconscionable — a hard argument where both sides signed voluntarily and the deposit was a conventional size. The numbers are invented; the narrowness of that door is real.
Three common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "The buyer breached, so the seller gets the deposit the next day." They do not. The brokerage must wait for a signed mutual release or a court order. Pressuring the brokerage is useless — it has no power to release the funds.
Misunderstanding 2: "A bigger deposit means the seller profits more on a breach." A deposit secures performance and pre-covers loss; it is not a profit centre. If the seller sues for more, the deposit is credited against total damages, and a forfeiture grossly disconnected from actual loss invites a s. 98 relief application.
Misunderstanding 3: "My financing fell through — that's force majeure, so the deposit should come back." Failed financing does not automatically excuse a buyer. If no financing condition was included, or it was waived, the financing risk is the buyer's own. That is precisely why the decision to keep a financing condition matters at offer time.
If you are in a deposit dispute now, do these in order
- Pull out the APS and confirm the basics: deposit amount, when it was due, who the deposit holder is, and whether all conditions were waived. Most of the answer is already in the document.
- Quantify the actual loss before negotiating: resale price difference and documented extra costs, organized with receipts. Numbers beat emotion at that table.
- Aim for a mutual release first. If one document can end it, do not drag it into litigation; anchor any split to the actual loss.
- If talks fail, see a lawyer promptly: the amount decides Small Claims versus Superior Court, and only a lawyer reading the file can judge whether a s. 98 application is worth bringing.
- Until documents are signed, do not believe any claim that "the brokerage already paid us." Without joint signatures or a court order the money cannot move — and if it did, that itself is a problem.
Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron. On deposits, read the contract and the process first; argue about winning and losing second.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Deposit forfeiture and relief turn heavily on the facts and the contract wording; consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: OREA Form 100 deposit clause; Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002, s.27 and O. Reg. 567/05, s.17; Courts of Justice Act, R.S.O. 1990, s.98 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026). The $50,000 deposit and $30,000 difference are illustrative, not a real transaction.


